National Preventive Mechanism Annual Report 2009–10
Children’s Commissioner
E
stablished by the Children Act 2004, the
role of the Children’s Commissioner is
to promote awareness of the views and
interests of children in England28 among,
for example, those working with children
and the government. The Commissioner’s
remit covers all children up to the age of 18,
or those up to the age of 21 if they have
a learning disability or if they have been
in the care of the state at any time since
the age of 16. Within this broad remit, the
Commissioner is to have particular regard
to those children who do not have other
adequate means by which they can make
their views known.
The Commissioner is supported by a
Deputy Commissioner who is also the chief
executive of the Office of the Children’s
Commissioner (OCC), an office comprising 25
staff, many of whom use the Commissioner’s
delegated powers to carry out their work.
These powers include the right to enter
any premises, except a private dwelling,
for the purpose of interviewing any child
accommodated or cared for there. With
the child’s consent, the Commissioner
may interview the child in private. Those
exercising statutory duties, such as a secure
accommodation facility, young offender’s
institution or immigration detention centre,
must also supply the Commissioner with
any information that she may reasonably
request. In addition, where the OCC publishes
a report with recommendations relating to
those exercising statutory duties, they are
required to respond in writing, stating what
action is being or will be taken to address
the recommendations made.
OPCAT compliance
The OCC does not carry out a regular
programme of visits as required by OPCAT,
but instead benefits from a very broad
power to enter premises where children may
be detained. This remit and accompanying
set of powers is used on a regular basis to
inform the OCC’s work. The OCC’s focus on
the views and interests of children is useful
given that they are potentially a particularly
vulnerable group of detainees. OCC reports
may therefore highlight or uncover issues
that may otherwise not be noted by other
organisations. Of particular note is the
Commissioner’s duty to have regard to the
United Nations Convention on the Rights
of the Child in her work, in line with Article
19(b) of OPCAT.29
Summary of activities and
key issues
A key issue for the OCC is the detention
of children for the purpose of immigration
control. The majority of such children
are detained in Yarl’s Wood Immigration
Removal Centre in England, a facility visited
by the OCC three times in four years due
to concerns about their treatment. In May
2009, the OCC published a report following
one such visit,30 the purpose of which was
to examine the provision and conditions at
the centre and to hear from children and
their families about their experiences of the
detention process.
The OCC identified several areas of concern
during the visit, not least the fact of
detention itself. It felt that depriving children
of their liberty for administrative purposes
was never likely to be in their best interests
28 The Commissioner also has a role in promoting the awareness of the views and interests of children in the rest of the UK in
relation to non-devolved matters (such as immigration issues or, in relation to Wales only, youth justice).
29 Article 19(b) requires NPMs to take into consideration “the relevant norms of the United Nations.”
30 Children’s Commissioner, The arrest and detention of children subject to immigration control: a report following the
Children’s Commissioner for England’s visit to Yarl’s Wood Immigration Removal Centre (2009).
36
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents