Section Four National Preventive Mechanism member profiles
is concerned at potential gaps in the NPM’s
coverage in Northern Ireland, including those
detained by the military and those detained by
HM Revenues & Custom.
and court custody. This involved visiting
courthouses across Northern Ireland and
monitoring escort vans, as well as interviews
with detainees, staff and other stakeholders.
Given the breadth of CJINI’s remit, designation
as an NPM member has prompted it to
increase its focus on inspecting places of
detention, leading to its first inspections of
police custody, prisoner escorting and court
custody. Although CJINI was engaging in
collaborative work prior to designation as
a member of the UK’s NPM, designation
has strengthened its collaborative working
arrangements and encouraged the sharing of
information with its fellow NPM members.
During the year, CJINI published thematic
reviews on prison staff training and
development; life sentence prisoners making
the transition to living in the community;
mental health and the criminal justice system;
and vulnerable prisoners.72
Summary of activities
In 2009–10, CJINI inspected several places
and types of detention and reviewed certain
themes relating to detention. It carried out two
unannounced inspections of the juvenile justice
centre as well as fieldwork for the inspection
of Magilligan, one of two prisons for adult
males in Northern Ireland. In conjunction with
HMIP, CJINI published a report of an inspection
of Maghaberry, the other male prison. This
inspection identified concerns in all four tests
of a ‘healthy prison’: safety, respect, purposeful
activity, and resettlement. The inspection found
immediate attention was required to improve
governance and accountability arrangements,
to improve the relationship between the
prison and Prison HQ, and to make changes to
established working practices. During the year,
the Chief Inspector of CJINI also conducted an
unannounced visit to Maghaberry to observe a
major search operation.
In June 2009, CJINI published its first inspection
of police custody. Overall, custody services
performed to an acceptable standard but
some concerns were identified. For example,
CJINI noted the high cost of delivering forensic
medical services in police custody and
expressed concern about the inappropriate
use of police custody as a place of safety for
individuals with mental health problems.
CJINI also carried out fieldwork for its first
inspection of prisoner escorting arrangements
Key issues
A number of key issues have arisen during
the course of CJINI’s inspections of places
of detention. One recurring area of concern
is the mental health of detainees. In 2010,
CJINI published a thematic report on this
issue. It recommended that those with
mental disorders be diverted from custody as
prisons are not therapeutic environments and
generally have a negative impact on mental
health. For those who are imprisoned, the
quality of care must be improved.
Another key issue arising from CJINI’s work
relates to the care of vulnerable prisoners. CJINI’s
thematic review of vulnerable prisoners was
carried out following the suicide of a prisoner
in Maghaberry. The review noted significant
concerns. The day-to-day regime for vulnerable
prisoners was inadequate for their ongoing
care and they spent too long in their cells.
The assessment and monitoring of prisoners
at risk was also found to be inconsistent.
Looking forward
In the next year, CJINI will continue its inspection
programme and will carry out a thematic review
of how prisoners are prepared for their release
from prison. CJINI will also continue to monitor
issues identified this year, including
recommendations made as a result of its
inspection of Maghaberry. That inspection found
that conditions for prisoners were an ongoing
cause for concern: only 54% of
recommendations made during the previous
inspection had been achieved. CJINI will
continue to press for implementation of the
recommendations and to monitor the treatment
and conditions of prisoners held there.
72 CJINI, Prison Service staff training and development: an inspection of the training and development of operational
staff in the Northern Ireland Prison Service (2009), CJINI, A review of transition to community arrangements for life
sentence prisoners in Northern Ireland (2009), CJINI, Not a marginal issue: mental health and the criminal justice
system in Northern Ireland (2010), CJINI, Vulnerable prisoners: an inspection of the treatment of vulnerable prisoners
by the Northern Ireland Prison Service (2009).
57
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents