Integrating the Issue of Sexual and Gender-Based Violence in Detention Monitoring
7. COMPOSITION OF THE
MONITORING TEAMS
The composition of detention monitoring teams should be a critical consideration when
determining how best to include the issue of SGBV in monitoring visits. Monitoring
mechanisms should also take this into account when assessing the potential risks of
SGBV to monitors or to detainees/prisoners during private, one-to-one interviews.
Ensuring a well-balanced, representative and professional monitoring team is important not only for establishing trust, but also for building confidence in the monitoring
mechanism among detainees/prisoners, staff and the public at large. It follows that
if monitors are well-respected, their recommendations are more likely to be properly
considered and implemented.
7.1 Identity of the Monitors
Those who have experienced sexual abuse might not feel comfortable talking about
the abuse. Therefore, if monitors want to conduct individual interviews, the detainees/prisoners, whether male or female, should be given a choice about whom they talk
to. This should be done in advance of the interview if possible. Additionally, if it becomes clear during the course of an interview that the detainee/prisoner is not comfortable discussing certain issues with the interviewer, then, if possible, they should
be given the opportunity to reconvene at a later time/date with a different person.
It should be noted that it is not necessarily the case that female and male detainees would
feel more comfortable talking about SGBV with members of their own sex. This may depend on the identity of the person who abused them and on the specific issue, as well
as on their own personal preferences and cultural or religious backgrounds. Monitoring
teams should, therefore, have an appropriate gender balance for all detention monitoring
visits, so that they can get the best possible understanding of any issues of concern.
In addition, individuals of particular ethnic or religious backgrounds may only feel
comfortable discussing issues of SGBV with persons of similar backgrounds, LGBTI
persons may prefer to talk to someone from within the LGBTI community, and others,
such as those with disabilities, may only want to speak with someone who understands the particular issues they face. Interviews with children should be conducted
by people with appropriate expertise and training.
While it will not usually be possible to include a fully representative group in each
monitoring visit, monitors should assess the prison population in a particular facility
33
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents