E/CN.4/2004/3/Add.3
page 20
66.
Once the criminal investigation is completed, the question of keeping the suspect in
detention should be reconsidered if it is likely that, owing to an overload of cases, the
hearing or oral proceedings will not be held immediately. Suspects should be released if
this is not incompatible with the higher interests of justice and if some other way can be
found of ensuring that the suspect will appear for trial.
67.
Urgent attention should be paid at both the federal and provincial levels to
improving the detention conditions of persons in pre-trial detention. Particular attention
should be paid to compliance with article 10, paragraph 2, of the International Covenant
on Civil and Political Rights.
68.
Urgent measures should be taken with regard to the number of the prison
population, since overcrowding in prisons and police stations is at the root of the problems
identified with regard to detention conditions. The situation in the provinces of
Buenos Aires and Salta is particularly serious. Consideration should be given to increasing
the capacity of the prison system or reducing overcrowding by making use of alternative
measures such as early release, release on bail, parole, house arrest, night imprisonment,
daytime imprisonment, and furlough. No person whose pre-trial detention has already
been ordered by a judge, much less a person convicted of an offence and serving a sentence,
should be held in a police station.
69.
As far as possible, efforts should be made to avoid holding children or foreigners
detained under the immigration laws in police stations.
70.
The right of detainees to communicate freely with their defence lawyer should be
guaranteed. The shortage of telephones in detention centres, the lack of telephone cards or
money to buy them and detainees’ financial problems should not prevent them from
communicating freely and easily with their lawyer. Access to a free or court-appointed
defence lawyer or to one provided free of charge by a bar association or law faculty should
be facilitated. Ownership of a property should not be an obstacle to the use of these
services.
71.
The Working Group invites the federal Government and the provincial
governments to monitor closely the behaviour of senior and junior police officers,
particularly with regard to their powers of arrest and detention. Particular attention
should be paid to the criminal practice of falsifying procedures with the aim of improving
the police’s public image at the cost of sending innocent civilians to prison. The efforts of
officials of the Public Prosecutor’s Office to deal with this problem should be encouraged
and supported. In addition, any manifestation of racist, xenophobic, homophobic or other
behaviour that is incompatible with the full observance of human rights - which the police
are expected to enforce - should be punished.
72.
The Working Group calls on the Government to ensure that there is an effective,
accessible, rapid and straightforward judicial remedy available in the provinces where
police edicts are still in use and where the police still have the power to arrest, apprehend
or detain a person for committing a minor offence.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents