Fiji: piloting mobile video recording of interrogations
Following their ratification of UNCAT in 2016, Fiji embarked on reforms to raise the standards in the Fijian police
and reduce the acknowledged incidences of assault in detention. As part of these reforms, Fiji purchased 30 video
recording devices to be used in interrogation situations. New Standard Operating Procedures have been agreed to
allow such recordings to be admissible in court. The procedures provide that each recording is made on three disks,
to ensure the complete integrity of the evidence, and one is given to the suspect. With training, Fijian police were
encouraged to become more familiar with the recording procedure and to see the potential benefits. Fiji anticipates
that far fewer confessions will be challenged in court, reducing delays, police time at court and related costs.
Republic of Ireland: video recording of interrogation and use of CCTV
In 2006, the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture commended the introduction of audio-visual
recording in many police interrogations, finding that recording in the interrogation rooms of police stations
may have been a contributing factor to reducing the amount of ill-treatment alleged by detainees. The CPT also
welcomed a wider system of CCTV recording in a pilot project in Dublin whereby most parts of the police station
are being monitored with cameras.
Model practice for investigative interviewing
As police interviews represent one of the situations where the risk of abuse is high, in 2016 the UN Special
Rapporteur on torture recommended human-rights compliant minimum standards for investigative interviewing
that refrain from using any type of coercion (UN Doc. A/71/298). Interview practice must not resort to any direct
or indirect physical or undue psychological pressure to induce confessions.
When used effectively, professional investigative interview techniques increase the quality and likelihood of
obtaining relevant information from a suspect, which in turn supports the credibility of investigations, the fairness
and outcomes of criminal prosecutions, and overall trust of citizens in the administration of justice and in their
police services. (See CTI Training Tool 1/2017 Investigative Interviewing)
In addition to a non-coercive approach, a number of associated good practices should accompany the police
interview. The time and place of all interrogations should be recorded, together with the names of all those
present and this information should also be available for the purposes of judicial or administrative proceedings.
Rules should also provide clear minimum procedures and limits for interviews, and provide for refreshment
and rest breaks. Additional considerations are needed for child suspects, witnesses and victims, such as being
accompanied by a responsible guardian.
Indonesia: training on non-coercive techniques in line with criminal procedure code
In Indonesia, article 117(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code provides that all evidence must be given without
pressure of any kind. In order to be more effective and ensure the integrity of interview evidence, Indonesia
has recently begun to train its police to use non-coercive investigative interviews rather than a traditional
interrogation model which had prioritised a confession.
TOOL: Safeguards in the first hours of police detention
7/11