IRCT REGIONAL REPORT 2016
In CIR’s experience, torture victims are not systematically
identified in Italy as it largely happens on an ad-hoc basis
depending on the competence and training of the relevant
authorities.15 Torture victims may never be identified and
may go through the entire procedure without ever bringing up their experiences to involuntary avoidance and
disassociation – both common psychological consequences of torture. Once identified, torture victims are provided
with special procedural guarantees, including prioritised
interview times. This means that their application will
normally take precedent over others. This is also the case
when the asylum authorities receive MLRs indicating that
torture and ill-treatment has taken place.
One of the problems with the lack of identification is that
it can potentially negate the safeguards torture victims
have. While the detention rate of asylum seekers in Italy
is generally low, there is no systematic way to identify
torture victims in detention facilities, which means that
it is possible for victims to be placed in detention. Once
torture victims have filed their asylum claim and enter
the asylum procedure, in the experience of CIR,
they are not accorded adequate reception conditions.
In the past, there used to be specialised centres for
vulnerable groups but this is no longer the case. There
are now two different types of reception facilities in
the country: First reception centres and second reception centres. The first reception centres are large-scale
facilities run by the government, whereas the second
reception centres are much smaller in scale and run by
local authorities who often delegate the actual implementation to NGOs. Asylum seekers housed in the large-scale
facilities receive varying degrees of assistance, depending
on where they are and who runs the facility. Coordination
between service-providers is generally poor, meaning that
vulnerable asylum seekers might not have their special
reception needs catered for. The smaller reception facilities do provide psychosocial support, including counselling, to vulnerable asylum seekers.16
Access to healthcare is another challenge facing torture
victims when they arrive in Italy. Asylum seekers arriving
by sea automatically undergo a medical examination, typically carried out by Medecins Sans Frontier. This examination is for all asylum seekers, not just torture victims, and
is limited to the identification of communicable diseases,
such as tuberculosis. Some vulnerable groups, such as
unaccompanied minors, are singled out in this examination but this does not include torture victims.
application
Italy, 2010 - 2015
Asylum applicationsAsylum
in Italy,
2010 –in2015
90,000
83,245
80,000
70,000
64,625
60,000
50,000
40,335
40,000
30,000
26,620
20,000
10,000
17,350
10,005
0
2010
2011
2012
2013
page 30
2014
2015
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents