syndrome will be imaged as muscle fibrosis. Bone bruises
can be detected by MRI or scintigraphy. Bone bruises
usually heal without leaving traces.
component of the physical examination. Dental care may
be purposefully withheld to allow caries, gingivitis or
tooth abscesses to worsen. A careful dental history should
be taken, and, if dental records exist, they should be
requested. Tooth avulsions, fractures of the teeth, dislocated fillings and broken prostheses may result from
direct trauma or electric shock torture. Dental caries and
gingivitis should be noted. Poor quality dentition may be
due to conditions in detention or may have preceded the
detention. The oral cavity must be carefully examined.
During application of an electric current, the tongue,
gums or lips may be bitten. Lesions might be produced by
forcing objects or materials into the mouth, as well as by
applying electric current. X-rays and MRI are able to
determine the extent of soft tissue, mandibular and dental
trauma.
3.
5.
Genito-urinary system
185. Genital examination should be performed only
with the consent of the patient and, if necessary, should be
postponed to a later examination. A chaperone must be
present if the examining physician’s gender is different
from that of the patient. For more information, see
chapter IV, sect. J. See section D.8 below for further information regarding examination of victims of sexual
assault. Ultrasonography and dynamic scintigraphy can
be used for detecting genito-urinary trauma.
6.
Chest and abdomen
Central and peripheral nervous systems
186. The neurological examination should evaluate
the cranial nerves, sensory organs and peripheral nervous
system, checking for both motor and sensory neuropathies related to possible trauma, vitamin deficiencies or
disease. Cognitive ability and mental status must also be
evaluated (see chapter VI, sect. C). In patients who report
being suspended, special emphasis on examination for
brachial plexopathy (asymmetrical hand strength, wrist
drop, arm weakness with variable sensory and tendon
reflexes) is necessary. Radiculopathies, other neuropathies, cranial nerve deficits, hyperalgesia, parasthesias,
hyperaesthesia, change in position, temperature sensation, motor function, gait and coordination may all result
from trauma associated with torture. In patients with a
history of dizziness and vomiting, a vestibular examination should be conducted, and evidence of nystagmus
noted. Radiological evaluation should include MRI or CT.
MRI is preferred over CT for radiological evaluation of
the brain and posterior fossae.
183. Examination of the trunk, in addition to noting
lesions of the skin, should be directed towards detecting
regions of pain, tenderness or discomfort that would
reflect underlying injuries of the musculature, ribs or
abdominal organs. The examiner must consider the possibility of intramuscular, retroperitoneal and intraabdominal haematomas, as well as laceration or rupture of
an internal organ. Ultrasonography, CT and bone scintigraphy should be used, when realistically available, to confirm such injuries. Routine examination of the cardiovascular system, lungs and abdomen should be performed in
the usual manner. Pre-existing respiratory disorders are
likely to be aggravated in custody, and new respiratory
disorders frequently develop.
4. Musculoskeletal system
184. Complaints of musculoskeletal aches and pains
are very common in survivors of torture.75 They may be
the result of repeated beatings, suspension, other positional torture or the general physical environment of
detention.76 They may also be somatic (see chapter VI,
sect. B.2). While they are non-specific, they should be
documented. They often respond well to sympathetic
physiotherapy.77 Physical examination of the skeleton
should include testing for mobility of joints, the spine and
the extremities. Pain with motion, contracture, strength,
evidence of compartment syndrome, fractures with or
without deformity and dislocations should all be noted.
Suspected dislocations, fractures and osteomyelitis
should be evaluated with radiographs. For suspected
osteomyelitis, routine radiographs should be taken, followed by three-phase bone scintigraphy. Injuries to tendons, ligaments and muscles are best evaluated with MRI,
but arthrography can also be performed. In the acute
stage, this can detect haemorrhage and possible muscle
tears. Muscles usually heal completely without scarring;
thus, later imaging studies will be negative. Under MRI
and CT, denervated muscles and chronic compartment
D. Examination and evaluation following
specific forms of torture
187. The following discussion is not meant to be an
exhaustive discussion of all forms of torture, but it is
intended to describe in more detail the medical aspects of
many of the more common forms of torture. For each
lesion and for the overall pattern of lesions, the physician
should indicate the degree of consistency between it and
the attribution given by the patient. The following terms
are generally used:
(a) Not consistent: the lesion could not have been
caused by the trauma described;
(b) Consistent with: the lesion could have been caused
by the trauma described, but it is non-specific and there
are many other possible causes;
(c) Highly consistent: the lesion could have been
caused by the trauma described, and there are few other
possible causes;
(d) Typical of: this is an appearance that is usually
found with this type of trauma, but there are other possible
causes;
75
See footnote 73 above.
D. Forrest, “Examination for the late physical after-effects of
torture”, Journal of Clinical Forensic Medicine, vol. 6 (1999), pp. 4-13.
77
See footnote 73 above.
76
36
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents