Table 1: Reform progress to date = Area of reform 1. Interpretation of INTERPOL’s Rules (Paras 43 to 50) 2. Protection against abuse (Paras 30 to 36) 3. Effective redress mechanism (Paras 37 to 42) 8 Fair Trials’ Recommendation Progress to date • Provide detailed information on how it interprets Article 3 Insight provided through published CCF decision excerpts (Para 138) - Publication of the Repository of Practice on Article 3 (Para137) • Commission and publish an expert study analysing relevant international extradition and asylum law and its own obligations No progress • Publish a Repository of Practice on Article 2 2014 amendment to Rules on the Processing of Data requiring Repository of Practice to be developed (Para 133) - Insight provided through published CCF decision excerpts (Para 135) • Make available information on how INTERPOL approaches the task of reviewing requests for INTERPOL alerts Limited information provided regarding the review process (Para 64) • Insist on the provision of arrest warrants with requests for Red Notices and Diffusions as well as complete factual circumstances No progress • Prevent Red Notices from being circulated prior to INTERPOL review Reform confirmed in March 2015 (Para 66) • Adopt a clear rule requiring deletion of a Red Notice or Diffusion when a request for extradition has been refused on political motivation grounds No progress • Adopt a clear rule requiring deletion of a Red Notice or Diffusion when asylum has been granted Refugee Policy announced in May 2015 (Para 116) • Systematically follow up with the NCB in an arresting country to determine whether an extradition request was received and what was the outcome No progress • Establish time limits for NCBs to respond to CCF requests Introduced in CCF Statute (Paras 101 and 102) • Enhance the competence and expertise of the CCF Introduced in CCF Statute (Paras 92 and 93) • Create separate chamber of the CCF for handling complaints Introduced in CCF Statute (Para 92) • Enhance the disclosure system Introduced in CCF Statute (Paras 94 to 99) • Introduce binding, reasoned and published decisions Introduced in CCF Statute (Paras 82 to 84) Verdict