Chapter 5 Towards the Closure of Guantanamo: International Legal Obligations | 115
with regard to the Transfer or Release of Detainees
that the Uighurs had subsequently been resettled. 338 Kiyemba, therefore, denied
federal courts the authority to provide a remedy to the detainees it ruled were being
unlawfully detained at Guantanamo, undermining the decision of the Supreme Court
in Boumediene. It should be noted in this regard that, since Boumediene, the
Supreme Court has not issued a decision on habeas regarding Guantanamo
detainees.
276. Third, the Department of Defense has the authority to release Guantanamo
detainees, as the Department responsible for their detention. Following Executive
Order 13492, the Department of Defense conducted an interagency review of the
status of each detainee and concluded that 126 of the 240 individuals detained at
that time were approved for transfer. 339 However, about half of those cleared were
not transferred by December 2010, and now need to meet the requirements
imposed by the NDAA.
277. Notwithstanding these obstacles, the Executive branch has taken some steps in
recent years to accomplish its goal of closing Guantanamo. Following his May 23,
2013, speech at the National Defense University, President Obama appointed two
Special Envoys at the Departments of State and Defense, respectively, to pursue the
transfer of detainees designated for transfer. He also lifted the moratorium on
detainee transfers to Yemen, and commenced the Periodic Review Board (PRB)
process mandated in Executive Order 13567. In addition, since that date and as of
January 23, 2015, 44 detainees have been repatriated or transferred to third
countries.
278. In this chapter, the IACHR will make an assessment of the current situation of the
three categories of prisoners held at Guantanamo Bay: detainees cleared for
transfer; detainees facing criminal charges before military commissions; and
detainees designated for continued detention (or who had been charged but are
currently not considered for prosecution).
A.
Detainees cleared for transfer
279. The U.S. Government uses the term “release” to mean release from confinement
without the need for continuing security measures in the receiving country, while
the term “transfer” is used to mean release from confinement subject to appropriate
security measures. 340 A detainee is deemed eligible for transfer “if any threat he
poses could be sufficiently mitigated through feasible and appropriate security
measures.”341 Therefore, an approval for transfer is not a determination that the
338
339
340
341
Kiyemba v. Obama, 563 U.S. (2011).
Final
Report,
Guantanamo
Review
Task
Force,
January
22,
2010.
Available
http://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/ag/legacy/2010/06/02/guantanamo-review-final-report.pdf
Final Report, Guantanamo Review Task Force, January 22, 2010, p. 3.
Final Report, Guantanamo Review Task Force, January 22, 2010, p. 7.
at:
Inter-American Commission on Human Rights | IACHR
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents