1 – BACKGROUND
The National Agency for the Prevention of Torture
is Germany’s designated National Preventive
Mechanism (NPM). By establishing this Agency, the
Federal Republic of Germany abided by its
obligations under international law following from the
Optional Protocol to the United Nations Convention
against Torture and other Cruel, Inhuman and
Degrading Treatment or Punishment (OPCAT). The
National Agency is only responsible for places where
persons are or may be deprived of their liberty, either
by virtue of an order given by a public authority or at
its instigation or with its explicit consent or
acquiescence. The following provides an overview of
the National Agency’s special status, as well as further
background information regarding its structure.
NGOs will be given the opportunity to propose to the
Conference of Justice Ministers candidates for
positions at the Joint Commission.” Members are not
subject to supervisory control or legal oversight, and
are independent in the exercise of their functions.
They act in an honorary capacity. Strict conditions
apply for the removal of members before the end of
their term in office, as set out in sections 21 and 24 of
the German Judiciary Act. The full-time secretariat is
based in Wiesbaden and is affiliated with the
organisational structure of the Centre for
Criminology [Kriminologische Zentralstelle e.V.].
1.2 – TASKS
The principle task of the National Agency is to visit
places of detention to draw attention to deficiencies,
and to make recommendations and suggestions to the
authorities for improving the situation of detainees
and for preventing torture and other abuse. Under
Article 4 (1) of the OPCAT, a place of detention is any
place under a State Party’s jurisdiction and control
where persons are or may be deprived of their liberty,
either by virtue of an order given by a public authority
or at its instigation or with its explicit consent or
acquiescence.
At the federal level, this definition encompasses all
of the approx. 280 detention facilities operated by the
Federal Armed Forces, the Federal Police and the
customs authorities. In addition, the Federal Agency
is also responsible for monitoring deportations carried
out by the Federal Police. In 2017, 25,673 persons were
deported.
The vast majority of facilities fall within the remit of
the Joint Commission. Last year, these comprised a
total of 181 prisons with independent organisational
1
structures, approx. 1,270 Land police stations with
custody cells, all courts with holding cells, six facilities
for custody awaiting deportation, approx. 550
psychiatric units in specialist clinics and general
hospitals, 27 child and youth welfare facilities with
closed units, and approx. 3,500 homes for people with
disabilities. Some 11,200 residential care and nursing
homes where measures depriving people of their
liberty are or can be enforced are also classified as
places of detention under the above definition.
1.1 – INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK
The objective of preventing torture and abuse is laid
down in the OPCAT, which adds a preventive
approach to the UN Convention against Torture of
1984.
Article 3 of the OPCAT requires that the States
Parties set up an NPM. These independent national
mechanisms engage in preventive measures and assess
whether places of detention ensure humane treatment
and detention conditions. The National Agency was
set up as Germany’s national mechanism for the
prevention of torture. It comprises the Federal
Agency for the Prevention of Torture (Federal
Agency), which is responsible for facilities run at
federal level, and the Joint Commission of the Länder
for the Prevention of Torture (Joint Commission),
which is responsible for facilities at federal-state level.
The two work together as a National Agency and
closely coordinate their activities.
Under Article 18 of the OPCAT, the State Parties
are obliged to guarantee the functional independence
of the preventive mechanisms and to make the
necessary financial resources available.
The members of the Federal Agency are appointed
by the Federal Ministry of Justice and Consumer
Protection, while the members of the Joint
Commission are appointed by the Conference of
Ministers of Justice of the Länder. In November 2017,
the Conference of Ministers of Justice decided that,
“in future, civil society organisations should be
involved to a greater extent when appointing the
members of the Joint Commission of the National
Agency for the Prevention of Torture. Therefore,
1
Federal Statistical Office, total number of prisoners and
persons in remand detention 2017, p. 6. (as at 31/08/2017).
9