E/CN.4/2001/66/Add.2
page 21
a large number had come (see annex). A number of the complaints also concerned the trustees
who were said to be provided by the guards with iron bars and wooden sticks or clubs and
maintained order by beating other inmates. The detainees indicated that the sticks were kept by
the trustees in their cells which were located at the entrance to the lock-up, in front of the guards’
office. These two cells were very clean and well furnished with mattresses and cookers, as well
as other personal items. Hidden under one of the beds, the Special Rapporteur discovered a
rubber club and two wooden nightsticks with handles, as well as some iron bars. Interrogated,
the chief of the lock-up indicated that the trustees used the iron bars to check the solidity of the
cell bars. No explanation was given regarding the presence of the three clubs. The delegada
assured the Special Rapporteur that she would take the necessary measures and would
investigate the behaviour of the head of the lock-up.
2. A pre-trial detention facility
57.
On 30 August, the Special Rapporteur visited the casa de custodia Muniz Sodré,
one of the provisional detention centres of the Bangu penitentiary complex. At that
time, 1,577 detainees were held in the 24 cells built to hold 62 persons each, i.e. a total
of 1,488 detainees. The facility is divided into two large blocks containing 12 cells each.
According to the Director, while Muniz Sodré is a pre-trial detention centre, around 40 per cent
of the inmates were actually serving sentences, which in most of the cases were being appealed,
and should therefore have been transferred to other facilities. In view of the overcrowding
throughout the state, the Director indicated that it was not possible to know when such transfers
would take place. He nevertheless assured the Special Rapporteur that convicted prisoners were
separated from pre-trial detainees.
58.
The Director indicated that detainees were let out of their cells four hours a day in shifts;
this was later refuted by detainees interviewed by the Special Rapporteur. Detainees claimed
that they were only let out of their cells once a week for two hours when visitors came. Cells
were clean and well lighted and ventilated. Toilets and showers were separated from the main
part of the cell. In one of the cells visited, 68 prisoners were held which meant that six prisoners
had to sleep on the floor. All prisoners nevertheless had their own mattress and blankets.
59.
The Special Rapporteur visited the punishment cells where, according to the registry,
eight detainees were currently held. Eight detainees, half-naked, were in fact detained in very
basic conditions. Most said that they had been punished for having fought with other detainees
and some complained of having been beaten by prison guards when they were transferred to the
punishment cells. All agreed that a dozen detainees, who were believed to be in bad condition
from the beatings to which they had allegedly been subjected after an attempted escape, had
recently been removed from the punishment cells.
60.
The Special Rapporteur then visited the cells from which the detainees being punished
were said to have come. Their co-inmates said that on 28 August their cell had been searched
after an attempted escape during the night of 26/27 August. They did not know why they had
been targeted, as the escape attempt was from another cell. After the search, some detainees
complained that personal items had disappeared. It is believed that because of these complaints,
they were allegedly taken, through the so-called Polish corridor, to the courtyard where they
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents