rights and builds upon CSCE/OSCE commitments.14 It also includes Chapters on Institutional
Framework (which includes sections on Policy, Legislation, and Administration), on Operational
Framework, and on Co-operation. The most significant OSCE contribution is in the Chapter on
Prevention, where the CIS states strengthen their commitment to using OSCE mechanisms and
instruments in the fields of early warning, conflict prevention and conflict resolution. The participants
also worked out a set of working definitions to systematise the types of flows currently observed in the
region.
Although the CIS Conference was an intergovernmental process, the views and ideas of the nongovernmental organisations and other independent actors were taken into account. The Secretariat of
the Conference held four meetings with NGOs (in Washington, Tbilisi, Moscow, and Geneva) and two
meetings with representatives of the academic community (in Washington in Paris) to discuss the
Conference process. In addition, NGOs were invited to submit their comments on drafts of the
Programme of Action. Many of these comments found reflection in the final version of the Programme
of Action.
Regional conferences on migration and refugee matters have taken place in other parts of the world.
Examples of such endeavours are the Comprehensive Plan of Action (CPA) for Indo-Chinese Refugees
and the International Conference on Central American Refugees (CIREFCA) that took place in the
1980s. The difference between those Conferences and the CIS Migration Conference is that the former
took place in response to large-scale humanitarian crises that already occurred, while the latter places
strong emphasis on prevention for situations that could lead to involuntary population displacements.
Because of prevention is one of the objectives of the CIS Conference process, the OSCE engagement in
the process was critical. In the future OSCE can still play an important part in early warning and
prevention. And, because the process of the implementation of the Programme of Action is about to
begin and political support for the process is still crucial, OSCE will need to be engaged in the followup to the Conference.
TABLE 1
TEN LARGEST POPULATION SHIFTS WITHIN AND
FROM THE FORMER SOVIET UNION SINCE 1989
Direction
Nagorno-Karabakh to Azerbaijan
Kazakhstan to the Russian Federation
Displaced inside of Tajikistan
Chechnya to the Russian Federation
Kazakhstan to Germany
Uzbekistan to the Russian Federation
Tajikistan to the Russian Federation
Azerbaijan to Armenia
Kyrgyzstan to the Russian Federation
Abkhazia to Georgia
Number
684,000
614,000
600,000
487,000
480,000
400,000
300,000
299,000
296,000
273,000
14For example, Principle 10(a) of the CIS Conference Programme of Action states that "The implementation
of commitments related to the rule of law; democracy and human rights are of legitimate and common concern
to all States." An explicit commitment to democracy reinforces and strengthens the commitments of the CSCE
Helsinki Document of 1992.
OSCE ODIHR Bulletin Vol. 4 No. 3
37
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents