1.
The rates of fees of kindergarten places in Keila town and Saue rural municipality
Case No 6-4/121345
Case No 6-4/130349; 7-8/130559
During the reporting year, on two occasions the Chancellor verified the lawfulness of the rate
of fee paid by a parent for a place in a pre-school child care institution. Both cases concerned
a situation where the local authority, so to speak, bought additional kindergarten places from
a private kindergarten / another local authority under a contract in order to comply with the
Pre-School Child Care Institutions Act. In comparison with the fees in municipal kindergartens
operated by Keila town and Saue rural municipality, parents had to pay more for the additional
places bought by the local authorities.
In both cases, a question of the legal nature of the contract concluded between the local
authority and the service provider arose.
Performance of an administrative function may be delegated to another person by an
administrative act/administrative contract or a contract under civil law. The conclusion of
an administrative contract requires a relevant delegating norm in an Act, but the Pre-School
Child Care Institutions Act does not contain such a delegating provision. Therefore, it is not
possible to adopt an administrative act or conclude an administrative contract for ensuring
the availability of a pre-school child care institution service via another person. Such a contract
would be unlawful.
PART II
The following part contains an overview of the selected proceedings in 2013.
PART III
The state’s intervention in the custody and visiting rights of the parents would be more effective
if in each proceeding concerning children the factors affecting the welfare of the particular child
and the impact of possible solutions on the child’s welfare are established, as well as the child’s
own opinion if the child’s level of development enables to express it.
PART IV
In the opinion of the Chancellor, to protect the interests of children in case of legal separation
of the parents the parents should be offered significantly more opportunities for using family
counselling and conciliation services. In doing this, it is important that the services are made
available everywhere in Estonia and are affordable for parents.
PART I
CANCELLOR OF JUSTICE AS OMBUDSMAN FOR CHILDREN
Delegating the performance of an administrative function under a civil law contract does not
require the existence of a delegating norm in an Act, but the preconditions for concluding a civil
law contract established under the Administrative Cooperation Act must be complied with. Inter
alia, a contract for delegating the performance of an administrative function may not regulate
the rights or duties of the recipient of a public service (child/parent) and by delegating the
performance of the service the local authority is not relieved of the duty imposed on it under
the Act.
Both Keila town and Saue rural municipality breached the conditions for the admissibility of
concluding the above civil law contract.
In case of Keila town, the amount of the fee paid by the parents of children attending a private
kindergarten arose from the contract concluded between Keila town and the operator of the
private kindergarten. Hence, the contract regulated the rights and duties of the recipient (child/
parent) of the public service. Therefore, the Chancellor reached the opinion that in this regard
the contract had been concluded in breach of the law and was void. The Chancellor noted that
Keila rural municipality had adopted a regulation on fees for kindergarten places and therefore
this regulation also had to be used to calculate the service fee paid by the parents whose
45
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents