or seminars with the coordinating committee and other relevant agencies and
organizations (this could be funded through international technical cooperation
programmes).
The concept of the plan should incorporate both international norms and features of
the local situation. In a series of meetings, the coordinating committee should seek to
develop an outline for a plan that is ambitious but realistic and embodies substantive
human rights commitments to be achieved within realistic time frames. This outline
can then be used as the basis for consideration by the government and for consultation
with the community.
8.2
Preparation of a national human rights status report – a baseline
study
8.2.1 General approach to the baseline study
A comprehensive and accurate baseline study is a key element in any systematic
approach to the development of a national action plan. For a country to move forward
towards better observance of human rights, it is important to know where it stands at
present. Many of the national action plans that have been published to date are based
on comprehensive human rights needs assessments that were carried out in some
cases by the United Nations. As a result, some have provided a broad-brush account
of human rights problems that need to be addressed, a statement of current policy and
an overview of what has been or is being done to address these challenges.
It must be acknowledged that such a detailed human rights baseline study may be
perceived as a politically sensitive issue that governments are reluctant to embark
upon. A baseline study will by its nature identify shortcomings, which may imply
organizational responsibility for deficiencies, and this may in turn have negative
implications. However, the willingness of the authorities to undertake a human rights
assessment is itself an indication of the political will necessary for an effective
national action plan process. Moreover, an accurate and frank assessment of pressing
human rights problems is essential to identifying solutions.
A thorough baseline study can, in addition, be a major exercise in itself. A baseline
study that seeks to reach detailed conclusions on the state of observance of all areas of
human rights requires investigation into health care, the education system and many
other areas of service delivery as well as into the administration of justice and the
existence of discriminatory attitudes. Countries frequently carry out studies of matters
of concern, and experience has shown that a comprehensive study of just one issue
can take a considerable amount of time and involve substantial resources. It may be
suggested that, in extreme cases, a detailed baseline study may take years and large
amounts of money to complete.
If the baseline study is unreasonably expensive or prolonged, it may undermine the
whole national plan process. In most cases, the solution is to find a commonsense
approach to the preparation of the study. It is up to individual countries to decide how
they should proceed in the light of their own circumstances, including available
resources.
61
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents