7. Outstanding issues in effective prevention of ill-treatment
copies even without the patient’s consent. The problem is that documentation of nursing care constitutes
a part of medical records and the relevant laws do not
provide for the inspectors’ access to it. The Ministry
of Labour and Social Affairs has not been able so far
to secure the necessary legislative changes with the
Ministry of Health, which is responsible for this area.
It is necessary to amend the Healthcare Services Act and include social services inspectors
among entities authorised to peruse medical
records even without the patient’s consent.
Unsatisfactory standard in psychiatric hospitals
psychiatric facilities
Issue: Patients who cannot independently leave the
unit due to their medical condition have not access to
outdoor exercise on a daily basis. A number of facilities provide accommodation in dormitories housing
many patients. The pending reform of psychiatric care
aims to develop community services – many patients
would thus no longer receive care in large institutional
facilities. However, large psychiatric hospitals will remain the main care providers for several years.
A strategic approach is also lacking in terms of decreasing
the need for using means of restraint
psychiatric facilities
Issue: The legal regulation of criteria for the use of
means of restraint is not in conformity with the European standard. However, full compliance with the standard, including the principles of necessity and subsidiarity,
is hindered by a number of persisting issues. In practice, there is a lack of specific conditions for alternative
resolution of dangerous patient behaviour. At certain
workplaces, means of restraint are used preventively
and in the long term because of inadequate material
equipment and insufficient staff, without this leading
to any adjustment in the manner of providing care. Not
only patients, but also the attending personnel are in a
danger of injury and trauma. The health staff often do
not distinguish between treatment and pharmacological
restraints. State oversight is ineffective. Because records
of the use of means of restraint in the current form, as
laid down by the Healthcare Services Act (Section 39
(4)), only provide an irrelevant statistic, effective monitoring and inspection of restraints remains difficult.
Potential solution: The use of means of restraint will
not decrease without conceptual development of their
prevention and alternative means, and without a clear
signal from the Government that it will no longer tolerate care relying on the use of restraints. Constant
guidance and supervision is also necessary.
The attitude to the use of net beds has not changed
healthcare services facilities
Issue: Although the CPT has regularly recommended
to the Government of the Czech Republic to discontinue the use of this means of restraint since 2002,
net beds remain in use. It is unknown how many such
beds are used in Czech healthcare facilities. It is likely
that the number is much lower than 120 established
by the survey of 2012. However, the Government has
not yet adopted the necessary steps to implement its
2015 promise to the CPT that it would seek ways to
discontinue the use of net beds. Since then, in view
of the risks involved, it has been prohibited to use net
beds in sobering-up stations, but they remain a legal
means of restraint in other healthcare services. The
Ministry of Health remains inactive and some physicians are concerned that net beds will simply be replaced by other means of restraint.
Potential solution: Adopt a strategic approach that
would include search for and promotion of effective
alternatives to the use, not only of net beds, but of
means of restraint in general.
23
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents