6
A practical guide to the Istanbul Protocol – for psychologists
has paradoxically led to more sophisticated
methods of torture that do not leave visible
evidence on victim’s body (Jacobs, 2000).
Most physical symptoms and signs of torture, if there are any, rapidly dissapear (Finn
Somnier et al., 1992).
such physical evidence should not be construed to suggest that torture did not occur:
It is important to realize that torturers may
attempt to conceal their act. To avoid physical evidence of torture, different precautions
are taken in order to use different forms of
torture with the intention of producing
maximal pain and suffering with minimal
evidence. Especially under conditions of
raised awareness in the society, torture applied with these precautions and sophisticated methods may leave almost no physical
signs.
Contrary to the physical effect of torture,
the psychological consequences of torture
are often more persistent and troublesome
than physical disability. Several aspects of
psychological functioning may continue to
be impaired in long-term; if not treated victims may suffer from the psychological consequences of torture even months or years
following the event, sometimes for life, with
varying degrees of severity. (Carlsson et al.,
2006; 1992; Genefke & Vesti, 1998; Gurr &
Quiroga, 2001; Jacobs, 2000; Somnier et al.,
1992; Turner & Gorst-Unsworth, 1993).
Torturers know that by not leaving permanent physical scars, they help their cause
and make the work of their counterparts in
the human rights arena more difficult (Jacobs, 2000). For this reason, in the Istanbul
Protocol it is underlined that the absence of
• Psychological symptoms are often more
prevalent and long-lasting than physical
ones.
(See § 159, § 161 and §§ 260-261 in the Istanbul Protocol.).
II. THE PSYCHOSOCIAL CONSEQUENCES OF TORTURE
The potential effects of torture include cumulative traumatic experiences on individual level, family trauma on family level,
and community trauma on community level
(Kira, 2002).
1. ON THE INDIVIDUAL LEVEL
Torture is a dynamic process that begins at
the moment of losing liberty, involves a sequence of traumatic events that may take
place at different times and places, end-
ing with the release or demise of the victim
(Somnier et al., 1992). Sometimes it may continue or repeat again. This cascade of events
may start again within a short time-frame,
without leaving any time for the individual
to recover. The person experiences complete
uncontrollability, inescapability, and is also
challenged by the unpredictability of the
torturer (Kira, 2002).
Generally torture has an extremely threatening and painful character, and can induce
immediate reactions of panic and fear, including significant fear of death, with a very