PART A – The importance of the psycological evaluation in the medical ...
5
PART A
THE IMPORTANCE OF THE PSYCHOLOGICAL EVALUATION IN
THE MEDICAL INVESTIGATION AND DOCUMENTATION OF TORTURE ALLEGATIONS
I. THE CENTRAL ROLE OF THE PSYCHOLOGICAL EVALUATION
Psychological evaluation can provide critical evidence of abuse among torture victims. It has a central role in the medical
investigation and documentation of torture
allegations. All medical investigations and
documentation of torture should include a
detailed psychological evaluation because:
• One of the main aims of torture is to destroy the psychological, social integrity
and functioning of the victim:
“Perpetrators often attempt to justify their
acts of torture and ill-treatment by the need
to gather information. Such conceptualizations obscure the purpose of torture and its
intended consequences. One of the central
aims of torture is to reduce an individual to a
position of extreme helplessness and distress
that can lead to a deterioration of cognitive,
emotional and behavioural functions. Torture
is a means of attacking the individual’s fundamental modes of psychological and social
functioning. The torturer strives not only to
incapacitate a victim physically, but also to
disintegrate the individual’s personality: The
torturer attempts to destroy a victim’s sense
of being grounded in a family and society as a
human being with dreams, hopes and aspirations for the future [...]” (Istanbul Protocol,
§ 235).
Internationally accepted definitions of torture acknowledge that provoking mental
suffering is often the intention of the torturer (Allden, 2002):
• All kinds of torture inevitably comprise
psychological processes (Kordon et al.,
1988)
• Torture often causes psychological/psychiatric symptoms at various levels
• Torture methods are often designed not
to leave physical lesions and physical
methods of torture may result in physical findings that either resolve or lack
specificity.
Improvement in the methods of detecting
and providing proof for physical torture