14
Gender and Security Toolkit
Women, men, boys and girls have different security needs, which should be reflected in
criminal law and legislation concerning security and justice. While women and girls are the
overarching majority of victims of GBV, men and boys may also be victims, not only during
conflict but also in peacetime.* It is essential that laws defining rape and other sexual
offences are gender-sensitive. Parliaments have the power to hold security institutions and
personnel accountable for effectively preventing and responding to GBV affecting women,
girls, men and boys.
LGBTI persons and others of diverse sexual orientations and gender identities and
expressions (see Box 4) often face particular forms of discrimination, exploitation, abuse
and violence. This is recognized by the many states and international organizations that
address discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity in their laws
and declarations.5 Discrimination, exploitation, abuse and violence against LGBTI people
include (but are not limited to) taunting and bullying for not adhering to gender norms,
humiliation, extortion and blackmail, sexual harassment and exploitation, as well as
various forms of physical and sexual violence, at times leading to death. In countries where
homosexuality is criminalized, LGBTI persons who are victims of a crime can be reluctant
to seek justice.6 It must be a fundamental goal of parliaments to defend the rights of all
constituents, regardless of their sexual orientation and gender identity and expression.
Box 4: Diverse sexual orientations and gender identities and expressions
Tool 1 explains in more detail what is meant by diverse sexual orientations and gender
identities and expressions. This inclusive phrase recognizes persons who identify as LGBTI,
but also persons whose sexual orientations are not (or not only) primarily heterosexual
and whose gender identities do not necessarily subscribe to a man/woman gender binary.
This includes non-Western non-binary gender identities.
While this Tool frequently uses the terms “man” and “woman”, it is important to
remember that some people do not identify as either or exclusively man or woman. The
discrimination and violence people of diverse sexual orientations and gender identities
and expressions face are intimately related to gender roles.
3.3 To achieve gender-equitable budgeting for the security
sector
Parliaments are able to shape gender-responsive budgets related to security that take the
diverse gendered needs of all constituents into consideration. To do so, parliaments need
to be aware of their budgetary oversight prerogatives (see Box 5) and be willing to exercise
them. In many countries, because of widespread acceptance that the areas of security and
defence lie primarily within the executive, parliaments have ceded their powers of initiative
to the executive in these matters. In comparison to other sectors, such as agriculture and
education, scrutinizing security and defence budgets poses an additional challenge due
to the sensitive nature of certain budgets (e.g. intelligence) and governments’ tendency to
overclassify information.7 Security budgets submitted to parliaments may not be sufficiently
detailed or itemized, which makes it harder for MPs to identify areas with potential risks of
corruption or to conduct a gender analysis.
Nevertheless, the parliament “controls the purse strings” and has a duty to ensure that the
security needs of women, men, boys and girls are equally taken into account. Recognizing
the challenge of overseeing security sector budgets, parliaments around the world are
seeking ways for enhanced parliamentary scrutiny of security budgets. In Germany the
parliamentary Budget Committee established a subcommittee, called the Group of Trust,
* For the purpose of this
Toolkit, the phrase “genderbased violence” (GBV) is
used to refer to all harmful
acts inflicted upon someone
because of normative
assumptions about their
gender. GBV is an umbrella
term for any harmful act
that is perpetrated against
a person’s will and is based
on socially ascribed (gender)
differences between females
and males. The nature and
extent of specific types of
GBV vary across cultures,
countries and regions.
Examples include sexual
violence, sexual exploitation/
abuse and trafficking for
sexual exploitation; domestic
violence; forced/early
marriage; harmful traditional
practices such as female
genital mutilation; honour
killings; widow inheritance;
and homophobic and
transphobic violence.
See UN Women (2019)
“Gender equality glossary”,
https://trainingcentre.
unwomen.org/mod/glossary/
view.php?id=36 (accessed 6
September 2019); OHCHR
(2011) “Discriminatory laws
and practices and acts of
violence against individuals
based on their sexual
orientation and gender
identity”, report of the UN
High Commissioner for
Human Rights, UN Doc. A/
HRC/19/41, 17 November,
para. 20.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents