E/CN.4/2006/7/Add.2
page 6
6.
The Working Group also held meetings with representatives of several non-governmental
organizations, including the bar associations, relatives of persons in detention and former
detainees.
II. INSTITUTIONAL AND LEGAL FRAMEWORK
A. Institutional framework
7.
The Constitution of Canada includes two main documents (the Constitution Acts of 1867
and 1982) and a set of unwritten conventions inherited from the British tradition. The focus of
the main documents is the division of powers between the Parliament of Canada and the
provincial legislatures, and the protection of individual rights and freedoms in the Canadian
Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which is part of the 1982 Constitution Act. Canada’s political
system can be described as a constitutional monarchy, a parliamentary system on the British
model, and a representative democracy. Most importantly for the purposes of this report,
Canada’s Constitution creates a federal system, in which the powers concerning deprivation of
liberty are divided between the federal level and the 10 provinces and three territories
(hereinafter “the provinces”).
1. Division of powers between the federal level and the provinces
8.
In the sphere of criminal law and procedure, legislation lies with the federal Parliament.
The provinces have the power to enact laws sanctioning minor offences. The administration of
justice, i.e. the establishment of courts, the initiation of criminal investigations, indictments, and
the prosecution of cases at trial, is within the competence of the provinces. Certain offences, the
most relevant example being drug-trafficking offences, are prosecuted by the federal
Attorney-General.
9.
As to detention in the framework of criminal procedure, sentences of two years and more
are served in a federal correctional institution. Sentences of less than two years are served in
provincial institutions. Whether the offence is prosecuted by the federal or a provincial
prosecutor, bail hearings are held before provincial judges or justices of the peace. Detention
before and during trial takes place in provincial detention centres.
10.
As for immigration legislation (and detention imposed in that context), the competence
lies with the federal Parliament and Government.
2. The courts
11.
The Supreme Court of Canada is at the apex of the Canadian judicial system. It hears in
last instance cases that arise both from the federal court system (for the purposes of the Working
Group’s mandate, this means immigration and national security detention cases) and from the
provincial court systems.
12.
Criminal trials in Canada take place before the superior courts and lower courts set up by
each province. The superior courts are constituted by the provincial legislature, but their
members are appointed and paid by the federal Government. The lower courts - provincial or
municipal courts - are created by the provincial legislatures and their members are appointed by