and that the accused have access to trained and independent lawyers. Furthermore, the Principles explicitly recognise the right to habeas corpus,596 the
right to be detained in a place recognised by law, the right of women detainees
to special protection, and the need for independent inspections of places of
detention to ensure the strict observance of all relevant standards. The Commission has explicitly taken these principles into account in subsequent decisions.597
Thus, the African system provides in great detail for a comprehensive system
of procedural guarantees. However, it should be noted that the Commission
does on occasion interpret these restrictively. In Purohit and Moore v The Gambia, for example, the Commission found that the inability of persons institutionalised on mental health grounds to appeal their detention, while falling
short of international standards, did not violate the provisions of Article 6 of
This right, along with a number of the other provisions of the Principles and Guidelines, had
previously been affirmed by the Commission. See, for example, Constitutional Rights Project
and Civil Liberties Organisation v Nigeria (1999), op. cit., §20–34.
597
See, for example, Zegveld and Ephrem v Eritrea, AfrCommHPR, Communication No.
250/2002, 34th session, 6–20 November 2003, §56
598
The Robben Island Guidelines, op. cit., §20(a).
599
Ibid. §20(b).
600
Ibid. §20(c).
601
Ibid. §28.
602
Ibid. §30.
603
Ibid. §40.
604
Ibid. §41.
605
AfrCommHPR, Res.61(XXXII)02: Resolution on Guidelines and Measures for the Prohibition and Prevention of Torture, Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment in
Africa (2002), §5.
4
The AFrican Regional System
The Principles are complemented by the Robben Island Guidelines, which
provide a number of procedural and other safeguards, in particular for persons deprived of their liberty. These include the right to inform a relative of
detention,598 the right to an independent medical examination,599 the right
of access to a lawyer,600 and the keeping of comprehensive records of interrogations601 and deprivation of liberty.602 Furthermore, the guidelines provide
that States should establish independent complaint mechanisms for persons
deprived of their liberty,603 and establish, support and strengthen independent
national institutions with the mandate to conduct visits to all places of detention.604 While these guidelines are not strictly binding on States in the manner
of the ACHPR, they do aid interpretation of that instrument, and the African
Commission encourages States to include measures taken to implement the
Guidelines in their periodic reports.605
596
135
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents