II. INDICATORS
In order to determine whether they are achieving the benchmarks they have set
themselves and to evaluate aspects of their performance and impact, NHRIs
should develop indicators.
As noted, indicators are used to track trends and identify changes in direction;
they measure dynamic processes. Indicators should be distinguished from
data. Data are units of factual information considered to illuminate particular
trends and processes.
Judgements and choices lie at the heart of the use of indicators, and for this
reason they need both to be selected carefully and evaluated critically. It is
particularly important to understand that an indicator only has significance in a
context, in relation to an objective or purpose.
1. Types of indicators
A. Quantitative indicators
Quantitative indicators measure things that can be counted. In relation to human rights, examples of quantitative indicators would be the ratio of health
care professionals to the population, the literacy rate or the number of reported
deaths in custody. In relation to organisational output, indicators might include
the number of reports issued, personnel trained or complaints handled.
Quantitative indicators are attractive because, in principle, they are comparable
and verifiable. In practice, they are not so straightforward. Numbers that look
simple and comparable often are not, but because quantitative data are
composed of numbers, they often appear to provide objective information.
Quantitative indicators have two main potential drawbacks:
▪
They may be used simply because they are measurable, without
considering in depth whether they impart useful and relevant information
about the issue in question.
▪
Complex social, political and legal processes can only be understood
adequately through qualitative analysis. At best, quantitative measures
provide snapshots of how things are at particular moments; at worst, they
mislead because they fail to reflect dynamic processes of change.
B. Qualitative indicators
Qualitative indicators are employed precisely because of the weaknesses
of quantitative ones. They attempt to assess the character of events and
��processes, as well as their changing nature, rather than count them.
Asking a target group’s opinion in a survey is a simple use of qualitative
indicators. Complainants might be asked to assess the response given to their
complaint; officials might be asked what skills they acquired during a human
Assessing the Effectiveness of National Human Rights Institutions 25
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents