E/CN.4/1990/17
page 48
allegedly beat prisoners held in that ward. It was alleged that the troops
had indiscriminately beaten the prisoners after the latter refused to leave
the ward in order to be counted, and that, as a result of the beating,
57 prisoners were injured.
152. On 5 and 18 April 1989 the Governement informed the Special Rapporteur
that Keraal Isiktas, who was described as an agitator and organizer of an
unauthorized meeting, had been taken into custody on 22 February 1989, on
charges of having violated Act No. 2911 on Public Meetings and
Demonstrations. He had been released on 24 February 1989. According to
medical reports duly prepared by physicians and an investigation made by the
relevant authorities, Mr. Isiktas had not been subjected to any kind of
mistreatment during interrogation and detention. No legal action had been
taken against Mr. Ali Meric, the other person mentioned in that context. With
regard to Hasan Hacioglu, Mehmet Nuri Ozmen, Timsal Sackan, Bercan Batur,
Ihsan Tekel, Glirdal Aksoy, Nadire Gliltas and Nuray Ariduru, on
23 February 1989 they had been taken to the court for the final hearing of the
case concerning participation in the activities of an illegal terrorist
organization called "PKK". During the hearing they had shouted slogans
against the territorial integrity of the State and had offended the court.
Although they had been acquitted by the court, the eight persons in question
pursued their illegal action even in the vehicle taking them back to the
prison for the completion of their release formalities. Once these
formalities were completed, they had been taken into custody on the basis of
the warrant of apprehension issued by the Public Prosecutor because of their
action during and after the court hearing. Allegations of ill-treatment
concerning these persons had been thoroughly examined and found baseless by
competent authorities. The medical reports established that they had not been
subjected to any kind of ill-treatment. The Government further informed the
Special Rapporteur that on 1 March 1989, some of the inmates in Ankara closed
prison refused to be counted and forcefully resisted the gendarmerie officials
(attached to the Ministry of the Interior and in charge of maintaining order
and security in the prison). As a result of physical confrontation between
the prisoners and the officials, some inmates (Ciineyt Kafkas, Abdullah Demir,
Hliseyin Poyraz, Hasan Huseyin Kaner and Mehmet Bayrak) had been injured and
taken to hospital for necessary treatment.. All of them had been cured and
quickly recovered. The medical reports indicated that none of the injuries
were serious. An official investigation into that incident was under way.
Once it was completed, the public prosecutor would take appropriate legal
action against all those who were responsible, and it was out of the question
that any official who had mistreated prisoners would remain unpunished.
153. On 16 March 1989 the Government of Turkey addressed a letter to the
Special Rapporteur containing background information on allegations
that 239 people had, in recent months, died as a result of torture or
ill-treatment while in police custody. The examination of 146 cases had
already been concluded and the results were the following: 10 of the people
listed as having been tortured to death while in custody were actually alive
and well. They included five persons who had never been taken into custody.
Thirty-four people had reportedly committed suicide; 42 had died as a result
of illness or other natural causes, and this had been verified by official
doctors' reports or documents issued by authorized health authorities; 22 had
been shot dead while attempting to escape from custody or having engaged in
clashes with security officers; one had been the victim of an ordinary murder
case, and three had died as a result of a hunger strike in prison. Thirty-two
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents