-44
4.MONITORING VIOLENCE IN PRISON
As explained above, violence is a complex and widespread phenomenon and
therefore difficult to monitor effectively. The following section aims to offer
practical guidance to NPMs on monitoring methodologies.
4.1. Setting the basis for the effective monitoring of prison violence
4.1.1. Gaining a good understanding of prison violence
From the outset, it is important for NPMs to have a good understanding
of prison violence and all factors contributing to it in general, but also in
specific country contexts. This understanding should go beyond the number
of violent incidents and other visible aspects contributing to violence and
focus also on non-material aspects that are often hidden but equally relevant
for preventing violence and ultimately ill-treatment.
The research conducted in the framework of this Project, however, showed
that NPMs tend to monitor only the measurable dimensions, such as
incidents of direct violence and material detention conditions, and rarely
address the factors indirectly causing and facilitating prison violence, such
as structural violence, the prison culture as well as dynamic security and
the elements underpinning it, including staff-prisoner relationships. To
effectively monitor violence, however, it is essential to take into consideration
all relevant aspects, also those that are less visible.
The iceberg model illustrated in Figure 3 can be a useful tool for NPMs to
visualise and map all the different dimensions relevant to understanding the
problem of prison violence and its root causes. The model shows that only a
limited fraction of the factors contributing to prison violence are visible, while
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents