General Report of the CPT, 2011-2012
on end. In their response, the Bulgarian authorities describe measures taken to
tackle these problems but also stress that progress is hindered by a lack of funds.
62. At Plovdiv and Varna Prisons, the delegation received a number of allegations of physical ill-treatment of prisoners by staff (punches, kicks, abusive resort
to truncheons). In their response, the Bulgarian authorities indicate that prison
staff are regularly reminded – including in the context of training – that physical
force and truncheons can only be applied when necessary to maintain security
and good order. The report also highlights that inter-prisoner violence was rife
at both prisons, a situation in relation to which overcrowding and low staffing
levels were contributing factors. The CPT has recommended the establishment
of a national strategy to combat this phenomenon and identified key elements
of such a strategy.
63. No allegations were received of physical ill-treatment of patients by staff
at Karvuna Psychiatric Hospital. However, at the forensic ward of Lovech
Psychiatric Hospital, the delegation heard several allegations of physical illtreatment of patients (including blows with a wooden stick) and of the use of
insulting language by certain orderlies. Shortly after the visit, the Bulgarian
authorities informed the CPT that, following an internal inquiry, an orderly
implicated in the alleged beatings had been dismissed while another staff member had received a warning.
64. The delegation found that living conditions were generally acceptable at
the Home for men with intellectual retardation in Oborishte. Further, some
improvements had been made at the Home for men with psychiatric disorders in Pastra, as compared to the situation observed by the Committee in
2003. However, the living conditions in Block 3 of the Pastra Home, which was
accommodating half of the residents, were unacceptable. In their response,
the Bulgarian authorities indicate that the residents concerned have now been
transferred elsewhere and that Block 3 has been taken out of service.
Report and response published in March 2012, CPT/Inf (2012) 9
and CPT/Inf (2012) 10
Report on the periodic visit to France in November/December 2010
and response of the French authorities
(treatment of persons detained by law enforcement officials, conditions in prisons, facilities for “difficult” psychiatric patients and prisoners suffering from
psychiatric disorders)
65. Most persons interviewed by the CPT’s delegation had no complaints
about the way they were treated when detained by law enforcement officials.
However, some allegations were received of excessive use of force at the time
of apprehension and of blows inflicted shortly afterwards; further, a number
26
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents