CONSOLIDATED REPORT • there are no detergents, not provided for by the Charter; • food is delivered from a military unit to employees under the Ministry of Defense, and separately to those under the National Guard - to military personnel assigned to this department. However, if there are differences, the report does not show them. In its response to the National Center for Human Rights, the Ministry of Defense indicated that the recommendations of the NPM teams were accepted in 2017 “for implementation, medical offices were equipped, exercise yards were provided with sports4 equipment, artificial lighting was provided in the military detention rooms of 5 regions”. Meanwhile, the Ministry continues to ignore the need to create a uniform approach to the conditions of detention 4 Akmolinsk, Almaty, Aktyubinsk, Taldykorgan, Shymkent, Karaganda military posts. 121 and to respect the rights of detainees and prisoners. Thus, if in the city of Aktobe in the military detention center it is forbidden to read namaz, in the capital there are no such restrictions (despite the fact that the previous consolidated report reflects an analysis of the provisions of law in this part with a definite conclusion). Unlike Aktobe, there is an equipped room for visits in the military detention rooms of the other two regions. If the list of rights in Aktobe and Astana is placed in cells, then in Shymkent it is “on the board on the wall”. For NPM teams in general, it is important to monitor the implementation of recommendations made on the results of a previous visit to the military detention centers (not on every recommendation in 2017 there is information on its implementation in reports), as institutions, in turn, have a very superficial approach to their implementation (since there are recommendations repeating from year to year, such as in Astana).