138 CONSOLIDATED REPORT to the insufficient number of herself regarding the use of compulsory medical such masks. measures against him or her SPE REM “Interdistrict is not heard and the right TB Dispensary” of the to access the protection Department of Health, is not granted. So this situation may suggest that Almaty At the time of the visit, the courts, by issuing orders there were 9 people in the for compulsory treatment, the procedural department for compulsory violate treatment. One of which rights of a citizen sent for is a woman (she lived in a compulsory treatment. Thus, the current Civil private ward). NPM members conducted personal Procedure Code of the conversations with patients Republic of Kazakhstan clearly and studied all the personal states in Paragraph 2 of Article files of patients. In each case 347 “Consideration of an there is a court order on the petition for the compulsory use of compulsory treatment treatment of a citizen in relation to the patient in suffering from tuberculosis the clinic. After examining the and evading treatment” decisions of the courts, NPM establishes the participation members noted that during of a citizen to be compulsory all of the court proceedings hospitalized, namely “The the person against whom case is considered with the the question of the use of presence of the person sent compulsory treatment arises for compulsory treatment is not present. Thus, in fact, in the courtroom, or at the the court proceeding takes location of the tuberculosis place in the presence of institution that provides the applicant (as a rule, this medical (dispensary) medical institution), the monitoring of this patient”. prosecutor (not in all cases). A conclusion can be drawn SPE REM “TB Dispensary” from this that the opinion under Akimat of North of the person himself or Kazakhstan Oblast.