E/CN.4/1997/7/Add.2
page 22
83.
The law and order situation appears to have shown some improvement during
the first few months of 1996. Statistics provided by the Government show that
only 32 persons were killed in law and order incidents during the month of
February, in contrast to 163 deaths during the same month in 1995. From the
highest level of 276 deaths in June 1995, the number of deaths has decreased
each month. That the city of Karachi was able to host the World Cup cricket
matches without major incident during the Special Rapporteur’s visit is a
reflection of the fact that some semblance of law and public order has
returned to the city of Karachi. However, the Special Rapporteur must
reiterate that he continues to receive credible reports of torture and
extrajudicial killings perpetrated by the police and Rangers.
V.
QUESTION OF IMPUNITY
84.
Although the Government of Pakistan has taken some positive steps to
improve the situation of human rights within the country, such as the creation
of the Ministry for Human Rights, the ratification of the Convention for the
Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women and the partial
abolition of flogging, there appears to be a lack of real political will
to address the issue of impunity. The Special Rapporteur has received no
information to demonstrate any serious effort on the part of the Government to
reform the police or judicial systems or to prosecute those responsible for
abuse.
85.
Provincial powers of appointment, promotion and deployment of police and
prison personnel are not subject to institutional systems designed to promote
competence, integrity, efficiency and adherence to the rule of law. It is
generally understood that corruption is rife. Many of the notoriously
underpaid and ill-trained personnel are generally thought to make ends meet by
extorting money from those over whom they have power. It is commonly asserted
that the jobs of such personnel, ranging from police recruits to station house
officers, from prison guards to jail superintendents, can be bought, with the
return on investment coming from the opportunities provided by unlawful
enrichment.
86.
In Karachi, the Deputy Inspector-General of Police provided the
Special Rapporteur with statistics on internal disciplinary action taken
against police from January 1995 to 1 March 1996. During that period a total
of 179 cases were registered against the police. In 51 cases the policemen
were dismissed from the police force, 50 received "major punishments" and 40
received "minor" punishments.
However, none were prosecuted for their
violations. This is consistent with information the Special Rapporteur
received from other sources. There appears to be a conviction on the part of
police and government officials that administrative disciplinary measures such
as dismissal, demotion and transfer are sufficient punishment for police and
security officials who have abused their authority. Although the Government
has stated its commitment to prosecute any officer found responsible for
crimes such as torture, to the Special Rapporteur’s knowledge none have been
convicted.
87.
The Special Rapporteur was informed that judicial magistrates are
supposed to make regular visits to places of detention to ensure humane
conditions and treatment of detainees. However, during his visit to Lahore
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents