Our Collective Conscience •
In one case, a female defender who had tried to address what she alleged
were cases of sexual violence against women inmates by security forces
was sentenced to 10 months in prison, later converted into a fine upon
appeal.43
8.
Retaliation against family members. Human rights defenders and their
families also face retaliation for their work. One defender’s husband was
beaten by unknown assailants, lost consciousness and had to be hospitalized
with a broken nose. The defender herself was subsequently beaten by police
officers who entered her home.44 Another human rights defender’s wife was
hit by police officers during a search of his house, and their relatives were
subsequently subjected to threats and harassment.45
9.
Threats by unknown individuals. Human rights defenders are often threatened
by unknown individuals. After publishing a report criticizing the security
services for persecuting the opposition, one defender received threatening
phone calls for over a month.46 In another participating State, human
rights defenders’ names were put on a website by members of an extremist
political party, and listed as “traitors to the nation”.47 Other defenders were
threatened by phone,48 and there were also instances of them being listed
on the websites of ultranationalist groups49 or far-right groups.50 Similar
incidents have happened to other defenders as well.51
43 Case of Eren Keskin (Turkey), UN SRSG, op. cit., note 15, para. 684; for the government’s
response, see para. 691.
44
Case of Elena Urlaeva and her husband (Uzbekistan), FIDH/OMCT, op. cit., note 19, p. 560.
45 Case of Azam Formonov and his wife, Ozoda Yakubova (Uzbekistan), FIDH/OMCT, op. cit.,
note 19, p. 552.
46
Case of Ramazan Dyryldaev (Kyrgyzstan), FIDH/OMCT, op. cit., note 19, p. 520.
47 Case of Svetlana Gannuchkina, Sergey Kovalov and others (Russian Federation), UN SRSG, op.
cit., note 15, para. 572; FIDH/OMCT, op. cit., note 19, p. 526.
48 See, for example, the case of human rights activist Alexander Zeković (Montenegro), who
received threats from unknown individuals that they would release information that “would compromise
him in the eyes of the population”. Information was sent to the ODIHR from the OSCE Mission to
Montenegro.
49
FIDH/OMCT, op. cit., note 19, p. 526 (Russian Federation).
50
Case of Katarzyna Hejna (Poland), UN SRSG, op. cit., note 15, para. 562.
51 See, for example, the case of Lida Yusupova (Russian Federation), FIDH/OMCT, op. cit., note 19,
p. 536.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents