LGBT persons in detention: risk
situations and factors
Once deprived of their liberty, LGBT persons become more exposed
to ill-treatment. Some specific risk situations for this particular
population have been identified. Participants especially highlighted
issues related to violence among detainees and the practice of
separating LGBT persons in prisons, or even placing them in solitary
confinement. Also discussed was the lack of training and knowledge
of prison staff and the institutional culture that sometimes leads the
staff to adopt hostile behaviour towards LGBT detainees. Finally,
some situations involving transgender persons were discussed
specifically and are dealt with separately in a sub-chapter later in
this report.
Violence amongst detainees
A person whose sexual orientation or gender identity is different
from what is expected in a heteronormative social context runs a
greater risk of abuse and violence at the hands of fellow detainees.
Indeed, participants agreed that LGBT detainees find themselves at
the bottom of an informal hierarchy that often exists within prisons.
Kyrgyzstan: the “untouchables”
In many countries of the former USSR, distinct, informal hierarchy
systems exist in prisons. In such systems, inmates identified as
lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender are rejected and excluded
by other prisoners and treated as total outcasts. Those relegated
to the bottom of the hierarchy are called the “untouchables”. In
Kyrgyzstan, the strong climate of homophobia and transphobia
that exists in society, and particularly in prisons, has a direct
impact on the work of the NPM. The stigmatisation of this category
of prisoners is so strong that the men working for the Kyrgyz
NPM risk being discredited in the eyes of other inmates and the
authorities by simply conducting interviews with LGBT persons.
13
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents