2.4.2 Eastern Europe
The existence of full and sustained engagement by both the government and NGOs
was noted by field operations as a key factor leading to anti-torture work being given
a relatively high priority in one country in the region, Moldova. Where relatively
conducive conditions exist on the ground, there is clearly a greater potential for OSCE
field operations to be actively involved in anti-torture efforts. Instrumental to this
active involvement was the acknowledgement by the authorities of the existence of
torture and ill-treatment and a degree of political will to tackle the problem. This
political will is often manifested in ratification of OPCAT and subsequent steps by
governments towards implementation, including, in particular, work done in
consultation with international experts and NGOs on draft legislation to establish an
NPM.
As in Central Asia, OSCE offices in Eastern Europe sometimes represent the only
long-term international “in-country” presence and report that they are seen as
important partners in torture-prevention activity. This fact is attested to by other
international organizations. Notably, several countries in the region have received
regular visits from the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and
Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, something that has undoubtedly
also contributed to the momentum for reform. Finally, the presence of a number of
local NGOs focusing on anti-torture issues, dealing with such matters as individual
complaints, detention centre monitoring and training, was identified as an important
factor.
One field operation, in Moldova, identified the taking of a comprehensive approach as
a major factor in their role in anti-torture work. Activities assisted with or
implemented by the field operation cover a wide area, including the facilitation of
conferences and meetings; visiting detention centres (both by the field operations
directly and in support of other bodies); dealing with individual complaints; training;
providing expert comment on relevant legislation (in the context of OPCAT
implementation in particular); and dialogue with national authorities, including
intervention at the political level, if required. The effectiveness of detention centre
monitoring, in particular, was underlined as a key element in positively influencing
the authorities to investigate and punish torture and ill-treatment.
All field operations said that they viewed a long-term approach to activities as an
essential component of an effective strategy. Seminars and meetings on preventing
torture have not, for example, been ad hoc events but, instead, linked to further steps
such as meetings, proposals for legislative reform and lobbying for new legislation to
achieve conformity with international standards. Activities have also been carried out
in co-operation and co-ordination with relevant international and national NGOs and
governmental bodies.
In one country in the region, Ukraine, the field operation has focused on support for
national monitoring of places of detention by police and has implemented a project in
co-operation with the Interior Ministry. Mobile groups to monitor police and pre-trial
detention facilities were established across the country and training on visiting
practices and reporting forms were standardized to ensure a coherent approach. A
website for the groups was also created with the support of the OSCE field operation
17
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents