E/CN.4/2000/9
page 82
day-old bruises on his lower lip which he would have sustained the day prior to
his arrest. The Department therefore decided to close the file on the complaint.
395.
Concerning Adel-Basset Ahmed Hassab Abdel-Moniem (ibid., para. 215), the
Government responded that he had been charged with operating an unlicensed
coffee shop and other charges, which were referred for criminal prosecution on
24 July 1997. The Government further replied that no complaint alleging torture
had been submitted by him to the Department of Public Prosecutions.
396.
Concerning Nasr Awad Mohmoud (ibid., para. 221), the Government replied
that he had been arrested on 13 November 1997 by the Investigation Unit of the
Kom Ombo police station, Aswan, in accordance with a warrant for his arrest for
possessing an unlicensed weapon. The Government further replied that he had
submitted a complaint to the Department of Public Prosecutions alleging that he
was assaulted in the presence of his two neighbours and an official watchman, in
an attempt to discover the whereabouts of unlicensed weapons. The Government
indicated that the Department of Public Prosecutions questioned the abovementioned witnesses, who informed it that a police officer and members of the
Investigation Unit accompanying him, went to his house and carried out a search.
The officers denied the allegations. It stated that a preliminary medical report
confirmed the existence of bruising on his neck and abrasions and swelling on
his legs which, according to a subsequent medical examiner's report, later
disappeared. The Government replied that charges were laid against the detective
sergeant and the head of the criminal investigation department but they were
dropped on 24 January 1998 on the basis that there was insufficient evidence for
criminal prosecution.
397.
Concerning Kamal Ibraheem Hamed (see E/CN.4/1998/38/Add.1, para. 94), the
Government replied that he was arrested on 10 April 1995 in accordance with a
warrant, on suspicion of arson. He was initially held for four days for
investigation, which was extended several times, and that during his arrest he
was extremely agitated and caused himself injury. The Government further
indicated that the police had recorded his attempt to commit suicide on 18 April
1995. The Government stated that he made a complaint to the Department of Public
Prosecutions alleging, inter alia, that he had been assaulted in order to
extract a confession. It stated that one witness confirmed his allegation while
another witness denied it. Two officers questioned also denied the allegations.
One officer stated that Emad Shehata Abdel Fattah caused his own injuries, while
the other officer stated that he was on sick leave at the time of the alleged
beatings, which the Government confirmed to be true. A medical report undertaken
indicated that his injuries were caused partly by some form of solid object and
partly by objects with a rough surface. The Government further replied that the
Department of Public Prosecutions excluded any suspicion of a criminal act of
torture and closed the case.
398.
Concerning Mohammed Ahmad Mustapha, Jaber Ahmed Mustapha, Youssef Abdu
Youssef and Atef Abdulla Razeq (ibid., para. 95), the Government replied that
there was no indication that they had been arrested in Port Said on 27 May 1995
nor had any complaints been filed by any of the men alleging torture. However,
the Government reported that Mohammed Ahmad Mustapha was questioned and later
released on that day.
399.
Concerning Mohammad Wagdi Mohammad Durra (ibid., para. 98), the
Government replied that the Security Forces received information to the effect
that he had been attending Islamic youth meetings at which he was criticizing
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents