3.1.3
The situations raised
Distribution of cases referred according to the primary grounds and type of person referring
the case
For each letter received, primary grounds and secondary grounds for referral of the case are given.
The last column of the table below shows the percentage of occurrence of different types of
grounds, taking the reasons for referral of cases as a whole (without distinguishing between primary
and secondary grounds). For example, although the main grounds for referrals concerning
difficulties with psychiatric hospitals appear to be procedural issues (30%), these grounds only
account for 16% of all the problems addressed to the CGLPL between 1 January and 30 November
2016 with a bearing on psychiatry.
In view of the small number of letters received concerning police custody facilities,
detention of illegal immigrants and juvenile detention centres, the primary grounds for the referral
of cases presented below only concern health and penal institutions.
Healthcare institutions receiving patients hospitalised without their consent :
Primary grounds according to the category of person referring the case
7
1
29.08%
40.16%
↘15.79%
12.46%
8.92%
↗14.15%
11.57%
6.32%
↘11.46%
8.61%
8.18%
↗9.36%
79
Medical treatment committee
7
2
2
2
Supervisory procedure
2
9
Other information
1
1
ACCESS TO HEALTHCARE
24
16
2
42
Access to psychiatric healthcare
14
10
1
25
Healthcare programme
4
4
1
9
Access to medical records
4
Relations with general practitioner
2
1
2
1
1
4
1
3
1
1
SOLITARY CONFINEMENT
15
15
5
2
2
Duration
7
8
Conditions
4
3
1
Grounds provided
3
4
1
Protocol
2
10
2
10
2
1
1
1
7
39
15
2
Traceability
RELATIONS WITH THE OUTSIDE
WORLD
5
2
Other information
4
98
Non-compliance with procedure
Access to somatic healthcare
3
% all grounds
combined (primary
and secondary) 2016
71
% 2015
Dispute of hospitalisation
1
% 2016
1
Total
13
Other24
Family / relatives
83
Association
Person concerned
PROCEDURE
Liberty and custody judge procedure
2
Physicians / medical
staff
Psychiatric hospital
grounds
Order of grounds
2016
1
21
1
1
24
29
The "other" category includes 4 referrals from institution participants, 4 independent government agency submissions, 3
referrals from individuals, 3 from trade unions, 2 from lawyers, 2 from patients for other patients, 1 from an MP, 1 from an
institution director and 1 "other" referral.
102
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents