party) and, without prior warning, had
thrown tear gas cartridges into the room
before dragging them down the stairs
to the entrance and then to the police
van, while subjecting them to beat
ings. A significant number of persons
interviewed displayed visible injuries
which were consistent with the allegations made. The CPT recommends that
a firm message be delivered to all law
enforcement officials throughout Turkey
who are involved in crowd control
operations, reminding them that
all forms of ill-treatment of persons
deprived of their liberty are not accept
able and will be punished accordingly.
Further, the Committee expresses
serious misgivings about the apparent
use of tear gas grenades within a con
fined space.
In their response, the Turkish authorities
provide information on criminal and disciplinary inquiries launched in relation
to alleged ill-treatment and/or excessive
use of force during police operations
carried out in the context of the Gezi
protests in Ankara and Istanbul.
58. The great majority of prisoners interviewed by the delegation at
the prisons visited stated that they
had been treated by staff in a correct
manner. However, at Sincan Juvenile
Prison, the delegation received a number of allegations of recent physical
ill-treatment of juveniles by staff. Most
of those allegations concerned slaps,
kicks, punches and blows with a plastic
pipe on the hands and/or the soles of
the feet, as a form of corporal punishment for misbehaviour. A large number
of allegations of a similar nature were
also heard from juveniles at Şanlıurfa
E-type Prison (where some of them also
claimed to have received so-called “welcome beatings”) and to a lesser extent
at Gaziantep E-type Prison. Further, the
delegation received many allegations
of physical ill-treatment by staff from
adult prisoners (mainly sex offenders) at
Gaziantep and Şanlıurfa E-type Prisons.
In their response to a specific recommendation made by the CPT, the Turkish
authorities inform the Committee that
they have instructed the management
and staff of all relevant prison establishments to demonstrate diligence and
sensitivity in their approach towards
juvenile inmates.
59. The delegation observed disturbing levels of overcrowding in some
of the prisons visited, in particular at
Gaziantep and Şanlıurfa E-type Prisons.
These two establishments, as well as
Diyarbakır E-type Prison, were found to
be in a poor state of repair. Further, the
overwhelming majority of adult prisoners in all the prisons visited were not
being offered a regime worthy of the
name; the regime provided to remand
prisoners was particularly underdeveloped. In contrast, as regards juvenile
prisoners, serious efforts were being
made to involve as many of them as possible in activities suitable for their age
(with the exception of Şanlıurfa E-type
Prison where the vast majority of juveniles had to spend practically the whole
day in their living units). In its report, the
CPT also expresses concern about the
serious shortage of doctors and nurses
in all the prisons visited.
In their response, the Turkish authorities
provide information on measures taken,
inter alia, to combat prison overcrowding and improve conditions of detention
in certain prisons.
Report and response published in January 2015
(CPT/Inf (2015) 6 and CPT/Inf (2015) 7)
Publication highlights ► Page 27
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents