-20
prisoners undergoing the same regime. This is a particularly problematic
type of isolation. Very often the procedural safeguards for the protection of
isolated persons are lower than those for disciplinary solitary confinement.
Unlike the latter, there are very often no defined time limits, and in many
cases it is prolonged for months and years.
2.1.4. Solitary confinement as a protective measure
Solitary confinement is also used for protective purposes. In order to protect
some groups of prisoners who might be endangered because of the crime
they committed, because of their collaboration with the police, because of
their sexual orientation or gender identity, or in some cases because they
suffer from behavioural disorders that make it difficult to live with the rest
of the prison population. Isolation for protective purposes may also involve,
albeit for shorter periods, those who have attempted suicide or committed
acts of self-harm, and often takes place on the decision of the health
authorities. In cases where isolation is used as a protective measure by
prisoners who feel threatened, alternatives should be found, and it should
be possible for detainees to spend some hours of the day with others, or at
a workplace or within activities where they are safe.
2.1.5. Voluntary solitary confinement
Some jurisdictions allow the placement in solitary confinement at the request
of a detainee. The reasons behind these requests are several: prisoners
might not be able to receive protection from the prison administration
in any other way, or it could be a reaction to overcrowded cells, and this
might be the only way to have a single cell for oneself. Even in this case,
it is important to remember that the detainee may still suffer from the
detrimental effects of solitary confinement even when s/he voluntarily
chose to be isolated, and it is important to look for alternatives.
In all these cases when faced with a request for protection, the
administration often responds with isolation. Instead of adding something
in order to support the regime of a person in difficulty, the response
goes in the opposite direction: solitary confinement.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents