-52
prison in run and other valuable information that would not be accessible
otherwise. A casual setting also helps set a less confrontational and more
cooperative attitude that helps better understand the problems faced by
prison staff and by prisoners with regard to solitary confinement.
One NPM also pointed out that it can be the prison director to point out
the members of staff to interview because they need to be sensitised to
the topic of solitary confinement. Interviewing the prison chaplain is
also very important because they can be a valuable source of information
to often identify problems. Interviews with staff can bring to surface the
hidden reasons for solitary confinement such as:
• Conflict management
• Understaffing
• Inter-prisoner violence
• Underestimating health consequences
• Perceived lack of alternatives to solitary confinement
4.3.4. Monitoring effects of solitary confinement on isolated people
As illustrated, isolation has particularly harmful effects on the people who
are subjected to it. If the NPM cannot visit the isolation sections with the
help of a medical professional (even if it would be desirable to always
include one in the NPM delegation), it is possible to recognize some of
the signs that might indicate the deterioration of the physical and mental
health of a detainee, which can be observed at different degrees and times
depending on the person.
Upon speaking with isolated detainees, it is important to notice whether
they present any of these symptoms and effects of solitary confinement139,
(see background for more details on the effects of solitary confinement).
Some may present these effects in a very dramatic way while others may
be more subtle:
• Difficulty maintaining eye contact (e.g. detainees look at the floor
when talking to the monitoring body)
• Evasive contact (detainees try to avoid contact)
139. Pétur Hauksson, Working towards harmonized detention standards in Europe – the role of NPMs,
Rome workshop on solitary confinement, Rome, via IV November 149, 27-28 January 2020.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents