BEWARE THE GIFT OF POISON FRUIT
Even outside an immediate threat scenario, it would be unrealistic to
expect security and intelligence agencies to abandon all cooperation
with States known to torture, particularly where there are strong
historical links and other demographic associations. Indeed, it
would be impossible to confront threats of international crime and
terrorism without such cooperation. Advocates for an ongoing
relationship with States that torture also point to the plain fact
that through cooperating with such regimes, meaningful changes
to abusive practices can better be achieved. In balancing the often
delicate relationships with allied partners overseas, States should
ask what positive preventive measures can be taken to ensure that
the relationships between executive agencies do not encourage or
lead to abuse.
These are certainly not easy issues to grapple with and we should
not assume that a clear legal prohibition is necessarily effective in
responding to the challenging legal and practical dilemmas that
States face. More consideration among expert actors should be
considered to weigh competing principles before guidelines for
executive actors might be adopted.
20
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents