CAT/OP/ROU/1
increase the institutional capacity for social reintegration within the judiciary and the
penitentiary systems.
36.
Although alternatives to detention have recently been introduced, interviews with
pretrial and convicted detainees and files on record show that the benefit of this change in
legislation and policy has yet to affect the majority of persons who come into contact with
the law. In particular, the delegation observed with grave concern that pretrial detention
does not seem to always be a measure of last resort, including for those below the age of 18.
37.
The Subcommittee welcomes the fact that the problems related to overcrowding and
material conditions in detention facilities are recognized by the State party and have been
identified as government priorities. In spite of some progress that has recently been
achieved, the delegation observed that overcrowding remains a serious problem in most
places visited and will remain difficult to tackle without a drastic move away from the
culture of institutionalization and towards the creation of alternatives to institutionalization
in the criminal justice, social security and health-care systems.
38.
The Subcommittee notes that detention should always be a measure of last
resort for all persons, especially for those below the age of 18.10 It urges the State
party to more readily use alternatives to detention, such as probation, bail, mediation,
community service and suspended sentences. Persons accused of a crime should not be
detained unless the crime is serious, there is a danger of the accused absconding or not
appearing at trial or the protection of the public or potential interference with
witnesses or evidence dictate otherwise. The State party should also ensure that clear
criteria for institutionalization in the criminal justice, social security and health-care
systems are set, that people being institutionalized are screened effectively to
determine whether the criteria for institutionalization are satisfied, and that
alternatives to deprivation of liberty are available more readily and efficiently. The
State party should also pursue its efforts to improve the social reintegration of
inmates with a view to reducing the recidivism rate and the prison population.
39.
The Subcommittee notes that, pursuant to the legislation,11 conditional release may
be ordered if a convict has served at least two thirds of the sentence, if the sentence is less
than 10 years, or three quarters of the sentence, if the sentence is 10 to 20 years.
Conditional release may be ordered earlier, depending on the age of the detainee and the
part of the sentence term considered as served due to the work performed in detention. The
delegation, however, heard many complaints about denials and postponements of parole
applications, even for first-time offenders sentenced to rather light penalties. Inmates
interviewed often did not understand the reasons for postponing their requests, found it
unjust and felt they had worked for years in vain, which creates a feeling of injustice
leading to frustration. Many inmates interviewed also expressed their concern at
discrimination against a large majority of detainees who are not provided with the
possibility of engaging in work or training activities due to a lack of opportunities within
the penitentiary system.
40.
In order to alleviate overcrowding in prisons, the Subcommittee recommends
that the State party systematically consider the possibility of release on parole when
the statutory requirements are met. It should also re-examine the process by which
the parole committee and the courts assess parole applications, to ensure the
transparency and impartiality of the proceedings. All decisions to deny or postpone
parole requests should be duly motivated and the information should be shared with
the detainee for potential appeal. The State party should also consider amending its
legislation on conditional release, to ensure that detainees who have not been able to
work due to a lack of working opportunities are not discriminated against.
10
11
8
See International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, art. 9, Committee on Human Rights, general
comment No. 35 (2014) on liberty and security of person, Convention on the Rights of the Child, art.
37, and United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Administration of Juvenile Justice (the
Beijing Rules), rules 13 and 19.
Penal Code, arts. 99–100, Criminal Procedure Code, arts. 587–588, and Law No. 254 of 2013, arts.
95–97.