E/CN.4/1996/35/Add.1
page 38
coerced through torture to make incriminating statements. Although a Human
Rights Unit was established in November 1993 within the Public Procurator’s
Office to investigate reports of torture, the Unit was said to have failed to
make public any information on the conduct of any investigations that it had
undertaken. Few complaints submitted to the Human Rights Unit by human rights
organizations or lawyers had reportedly been investigated.
183. The Special Rapporteur transmitted a number of individual cases involving
persons detained for political reasons, which are summarized in the following
paragraphs. A letter of reply from the Government was received too late for
inclusion in this report.
184. Ramadhan Mahmoud Ahmed, a lawyer, was reportedly arrested on 6 July 1994
by officers of the Abu Za’abal Industrial Prison, where he had gone to see a
client. At the Abu Za’abal branch of the SSI, he was allegedly tortured by
means of beatings, suspension and electric shocks applied to various parts of
his body. He was released on 9 July 1994.
185. Three detainees arrested in November 1993 in connection with the
attempted assassination of the Prime Minister, ’Atef Sidqi, were allegedly
tortured by SSI officers. Sayyid Salah al-Sayyid Sulayman was punched
repeatedly and suspended in contorted positions. Tariq ’Abd al-Nabi Hassan
al-Fahal was beaten and subjected to electric shocks on various parts of his
body, sustaining injuries to his nose and jaw. Tuhami Ahmed ’Abdallah Ahmed
Shalabi was subjected to beatings and electric shocks to various parts of his
body, including his genitals, and he sustained injuries around one eye and to
his left leg and right arm. Forensic examinations were said to have revealed
injuries consistent with torture on all three persons. Sayyid Alah al-Sayyid
Sulayman and Tariq ’Abd al-Nabi Hassan al-Fahal were sentenced to death in
Cairo by the Supreme Military Court on 17 March and executed on 3 May 1994.
186. Safwat Ahmed ’Abd al-Ghani, Ahmed ’Abdu Salim, Mahmoud Mohammad Ahmed
Shu’aib, Hassan al-Gharbawi Shahhata, ’Adli ’Abd al-Latif and Mursi Mohammad
Mursi were allegedly beaten repeatedly by high security prison officers in
February 1994. They had gone on hunger strike for at least 15 days to protest
their treatment and a ban on visits by family members and lawyers in effect
since 20 December 1993.
187. The Special Rapporteur also notified the Government that he had received
information according to which detainees at police stations throughout Egypt
were frequently subjected to torture or ill-treatment. The methods of torture
reported included beatings with leather straps, sticks and electric cables;
suspension in various positions accompanied by heavy beatings; beatings with
solid objects and application of electric shocks. During pre-trial detention
many suspects are allegedly forced to sign police records without knowing
their contents. The practice of such torture was said to be facilitated by
the following factors: that the Code of Criminal Procedure does not guarantee
an arrested person the right to seek legal assistance in the stages of
identification and during investigations carried out by police station
officers; that under the Emergency Law in effect since 1981 the Ministry of
the Interior is granted full powers to carry out administrative arrests
without judicial or prosecutorial interference; and that under recent legal
amendments, police may detain a suspect for up to 11 days without charge or
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents