CAT/C/39/2
page 52
220. On July 22 2005 the members of the Committee visited the Precinct of the 5th District in
Rio de Janeiro. At the time, that Precinct was already a part of the “Legal Precinct” (Delegacia
Legal) program and held no inmates. Today there are other precincts of this kind in the state.
221. On July 22 2005 the members of the Committee visited the Provisional Interment Center
(CEIP) at Belo Horizonte, about which there had been press allegations concerning torture of
minors. The Director of the Center had been suspended and replaced on the eve of the
Committee’s visit. The Brazilian state informs that the procedure set in motion at the time was
concluded on August 8 2005 and resulted in the Director’s dismissal. The documentation
regarding the procedure was sent to the Public Prosecutor, who filed for penal action on
July 22 2005 (Prc. No. 0024.05.573.362-0).
222. The premises of CEIP were restored and the problem of overcrowding is being gradually
solved. It is expected that on the second half of this year the number of places offered will be
three times that of 2003, from 420 to 1.141. The selection of the technical team is carefully done,
there is continuous training, including on the issue of human rights. A new socio-educational
model, based on educative intervention, has been adopted.
223. On July 23 2005 the members of the Committee visited the headquarters of Polinter in Rio
de Janeiro. The Brazilian State informs that the jail at Polinter was closed and is today used only
as a center for sorting and classifying detainees, as well as a halfway house for detainees being
sent to custody centers. Detainees spend no more than one day at that place, among a total of 10
to 50 people under custody.
224. On July 26 2006 the members of the Committee visited the provisional detention
center Padre Severino, in Rio de Janeiro, under DEGASE. The Brazilian state informs that
currently 100% of the adolescents are enrolled in the school.
225. On July 29 2005 the members of the Committee visited Bangu III in Rio de Janeiro. The
penitentiary encompasses two separate units and there is no overcrowding. The last rebellion
took place in 2003.
III. COMMENTS FROM BRAZIL ON THE CONCLUSIONS
AND RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE COMMITTEE
“Paragraph 178, The Committee found, as described in the preceding paragraphs,
endemic overcrowding, filthy conditions of confinement, extreme heat, light deprivation
and permanent lock-ups (factors with severe health consequences for inmates), along with
pervasive violence as well as lack of proper oversight, which leads to impunity. In fact,
there is widespread impunity for the perpetrators of abuse. In addition, the Committee on
several occasions received allegations attesting to the discriminatory nature of these
conditions given that they affect vulnerable groups and in particular, persons of African
descent. The Committee notes that. the government of Brazil, fully cooperated with the
Committee’s visit, constantly expressed its awareness and concern with the seriousness of
the existing problems, as well as its political will to improve. However, tens of thousands
of persons are still held in delegacias and elsewhere in the penitentiary system where
torture and similar ill-treatment continues to be “meted out on a widespread and
systematic basis”. The Committee has defined systematic torture by stating that “the
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents