E/CN.4/1989/15
page 9
prolonged periods of standing and - at least in one case - of enclosure of the
head in a plastic bag. Finally they had lodged a complaint with the Public
Prosecutor. The Special Rapporteur requested information on the outcome of
the investigation.
37. By a letter dated 4 January 1989, the Government of France submitted a
note prepared by the Services de la Direction de la surveillance du territoire
containing the facts of the case and the observations of the Government on the
communication transmitted by the Special Rapporteur. It was stated,
inter alia, that M. S. Kalibi and Miss A. Monachipour "... were each examined
twice by doctors, Hotel-Dieu interns who found no traces of injury on them.
Furthermore, when they appeared before the examining magistrate, neither of
the two complainants reported any police brutality against them. In view of
these clarifications and in the absence of any evidence to the contrary, the
Prosecutor took the decision to close the proceedings permanently".
Greece
38. On 28 July 1988, a letter was addressed to the Government of Greece
transmitting information alleging that Vangelis Katsikoyannis was arrested on
12 October 1987 on a charge of having committed drug offences. After being
taken to Hersonisos Police Station (near Heraklion), he was allegedly beaten
with whips and clubs, hung upside-down and subjected to the falanga (beating
on the soles of the feet) by five policemen. The medical judge of Heraklion,
Mr. Phrangoulis, testified to the existence of many injuries all over the
body, the hands and the feet, said to have been caused by blunt instruments.
An inquiry was initiated by the Deputy Prosecutor. The Special Rapporteur
requested information on the outcome of the investigation.
Grenada
39. On 10 June 1988, a letter was addressed to the Government of Grenada
transmitting information alleging that 14 persons were detained in connection
with the death of the former Prime Minister, Mr. Maurice Bishop, on
6 October 1983. In particular, Phyllis Coard reportedly continued to be
subjected to inhuman and degrading treatment while imprisoned in Richmond Hill
prison in Grenada. Prisoners allegedly continued to be denied proper medical
attention, kept in their cells for more than 24 hours at a time and their diet
remained inadequate. Reportedly Mrs. Coard was being held under constant
psychological pressure, was frequently put on "bread and water" and was
deprived of visits and letters.
Guatemala
40. On 6 April 1988, a letter was addressed to the Government of Guatemala
transmitting information alleging that Ana Elizabeth Paniagua Morales was
found dead on 11 February 1988 on the road between Guatemala City and the
Department of Palencia. It was alleged that her body showed signs of torture,
gun shot wounds and injuries caused by a knife. In addition,
Jose Alberto Grijalba Estevez was reportedly abducted on 16 February 1988 and
was found dead the following day in the Department of Santa Rosa; his body
bore signs of torture. Furthermore, Barbara Ramirez and
Dolores Pospoj Ajcabal were found dead on 27 December 1987 on the road between
Santiago Atitlan and Tzanchichan. It was alleged that their bodies also bore
signs of torture. Finally, Jose Mecia Ramirez and his brother Antonio were
reportedly kidnapped on 23 January 1988 in Tzanchichan, Santiago Atitlan,