MONITORING PLACES OF DETENTION : A PRACTICAL GUIDE FOR NGOS
119
Large-capacity dormitories inevitably imply a lack of privacy for
prisoners in their everyday lives. Moreover, the risk of intimidation
and violence is high. Such accommodation arrangements are prone to
foster the development of offender subcultures and to facilitate the
maintenance of the cohesion of criminal organisations. They can also
render proper staff control extremely difficult, if not impossible; more
specifically, in case of prison disturbances, outside interventions
involving the use of considerable force are difficult to avoid. With
such accommodation, the appropriate allocation of individual prisoners, based on a case by case risk and needs assessment, also becomes
an almost impossible exercise. All these problems are exacerbated
when the numbers held go beyond a reasonable occupancy level; further, in such a situation the excessive burden on communal facilities
such as washbasins or lavatories and the insufficient ventilation for so
many persons will often lead to deplorable conditions.
The CPT must nevertheless stress that moves away from largecapacity dormitories towards smaller living units have to be accompanied by measures to ensure that prisoners spend a reasonable part of
the day engaged in purposeful activities of a varied nature outside
their living unit.” CPT, GR 11, §29
Comments
International standards recommend individual over collective
accommodation. For various reasons individual accommodation is not
always possible. Collective accommodation should, however, be limited as regards the number of persons sharing it.
Where accommodation is collective, it is important to select those
persons who will be sharing it in such a way as to limit the risks of
abuse among detainees.
Overcrowding in detention premises is a frequent problem. This
concept is based on the relationship between the surface area (in
square metres) of the place and the number of persons living on it.
3
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents