5. Any body/board undertaking civilian oversight should consider developing
and implement a program of community outreach to educate the public on
the rationale and purpose of the new mechanism
3.4 Progress with Recommendations (as of 20 February 2017)
Less than two years since the recommendations were made there had been
little progress in the establishment of external oversight of police in the
countries where independence of oversight mechanisms remained an issue.
Continuance of oversight in countries which had previously established robust
mechanisms had experienced little change.
These systems had been
operating, for the most part, effectively, and good practice continued to be
evident in PONI, GSOC, and NBIPA.
Although there had been few outcomes regarding the establishment of
oversight bodies a few projects were under way to consult on and develop
models to reflect individual country contexts.
A project to establish better independence of police oversight in Ukraine
appeared to have stalled. The formation of a National Bureau of Investigation
had been ratified by the government in November 2015. In July 2016, a
competition was held to appoint the director, the first deputy and deputy
director, directors of territorial bodies and heads of departments of the central
apparatus of the State Bureau of Investigation, the staff of the internal control
departments of the State Bureau of Investigation. However, at the time of
writing the bureau was not in operation.
There appeared to be some progress in FYROM where a project to establish
an external oversight mechanism, supported by the Council of Europe and the
Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Kingdom of the Netherlands, reached
agreement that an oversight mechanism should be established. Consultation
at a round table event included representatives of the Ministry of Internal
Affairs, Ministry of Justice, the Ombudsman office, judges, prosecutors,
university professors, lawyers, and representatives from the NGO sector and
international community.
This approach reflects the assertions of
recommendation 1 above.
The preferred approach to be adopted in FYROM was the ‘two tier’ prosecutor
plus model with a specialised unit within the Public prosecution and the
creation of a new civilian review body with appellate functions.
72
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents