3) Documenting any technical features of the equipment,
which may be available on the weapon or restraint itself
or on the packaging—including, for example, details of the
characteristics and composition and length of the electric
shock produced, or the strength of the chemical irritant /
tear gas, and details of chemicals (both active agents, such as
CS, and chemicals used as solvents or carriers for the active
agent). —may be helpful in discussions of proportionality and
medical implications. Such factors are relevant for discussions
of necessity and proportionality (for example, as noted
above, is it strictly necessary to use, say, an unusually high
strength chemical irritant spray, when weaker formulations
may be effective and available), can help inform discussions
around whether current policy and practice is appropriate
and may also help in assessing medical implications, and in
identifying less harmful options.
4) Investigating the regulations and policies surrounding the
issue and use of equipment, and investigating whether, in
practice, the equipment has actually been i) issued, and ii)
used by officials.
5) In addition to following up with the prison authorities directly,
additional ways of following up include:
• Approaching the country of origin (including trade
control departments) and the manufacturer directly.
• Reading relevant procurement, tender and award
documents for further details of the equipment in
use, the manufacturer and supplier, the number of
units ordered and the dates ordered and received.
• Checking whether national or regional trade controls
in the country of origin prohibit the export of this
equipment, or require a license.
• Using the further sources of information listed in the
last section of this research to assist with researching
particular topics.
Section 3: Pocket book resource
This Section provides a practical tool to assist monitors working in this
area. It consists of a one page guide or aide-memoire, suitable to take
into places of detention, with key observations and questions that
can usefully be posed at different locations in the detention centre
(e.g. when in the armoury, when on tour of the prison, when speaking
to detainees and staff). This aims to relay, in a user-friendly format,
some of the key questions and observations listed in Parts 1 and 2.
However, given space limitations it does not include the full list of
questions and observations detailed within, so should ideally be
consulted together with the rest of this Practical Guide.
22
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents