National Preventive Mechanism Eleventh Annual Report 2019–20
Prisons
Significant concerns around safety,
overcrowding and deaths in prisons across
the UK remain. A range of reviews, policies
and plans were published in 2019–20, while
new legislation has focused on sentencing
changes, with some developments around
prisoner voting rights.
In our 10th Annual Report we noted that in
February 2019 the then Secretary of State for
Justice for England and Wales, David Gauke,
acknowledged the high rate of imprisonment
and proposed that caution be exercised in
continuing to increase sentences. He also
accepted there was a very strong case for
abolishing short prison sentences (with
some exceptions) and making greater use of
community orders, though no commitment
was made to legislate.40 Since then there
has been a shift in the rhetoric around
sentencing and crime, with a move away
from discouraging short sentences in England
and Wales.
New legislation concerning prisoners
In February 2020, further terror legislation
came into force following the terrorist
attacks at Fishmongers Hall, London and
in Streatham which were committed
by individuals who had previously been
convicted of terror offences and released
automatically at the halfway point of their
sentence on licence. Emergency legislation
was introduced under the Terrorist Offenders
(Restriction of Early Release) Act 2020. This
legislation retrospectively ended automatic
early release for terrorist offenders in the
UK serving standard determinate sentences,
requiring them to spend a minimum of
two‑thirds of their term in prison before
40
41
42
20
being considered for release by the
Parole Board.
The UK government intends to increase
further the length of prison sentences for
those convicted of terrorist offences under
the Counter-Terrorism and Sentencing
Bill 2020. This includes the creation of a
new ‘Serious Terrorist Sentence, with a
minimum 14-year jail term,’ for dangerous
offenders who risked multiple lives as a
result of their offending. The IRTL called
for the publication of statistics on the
success rate of applications for warrants
of further detention under Schedule 8 to
the Terrorism Act 2020. The government
accepted this recommendation in its formal
response published in October 2020.41
The IRTL also undertook an independent
review of multi‑agency public protection
arrangements (MAPPA), which was published
in May 2020.42
As well as the changes to sentencing and
parole brought in by terror legislation, the
Release of Prisoners (Alteration of Relevant
Proportion of Sentence) Order 2019 moves
the release point in England and Wales from
halfway through a custodial sentence to twothirds of the way through, for those convicted
of relevant violent and sexual offences. This
Order was part of the current government’s
election manifesto and follows the significant
controversy around the release on licence of a
taxi driver, found guilty of 19 sexual offences,
who had served the minimum term of a (now
repealed) indeterminate ‘Imprisonment for
Public Protection’ sentence. The Order came
into force on 1 April 2020 and its provisions
have the effect of modifying the application
of relevant sentences of imprisonment (under
s. 237(1) of the Criminal Justice Act 2003)
MoJ, February 2019, ‘Beyond prison, redefining punishment’: David Gauke speech, https://www.gov.uk/government/
speeches/beyond-prison-redefining-punishment-david-gauke-speech [accessed 24/08/2020]
UK Government, October 2020, Response to the operation of the Terrorism Acts in 2018 Report, https://www.gov.uk/
government/publications/response-to-the-operation-of-the-terrorism-acts-in-2018-report, [accessed 01/12/2020]
This review was published May 2020, available: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/
uploads/attachment_data/file/913983/supervision-terrorism-and-terrorism-risk-offenders-review.pdf [accessed 14/10/2020]
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents