A/HRC/25/60
information. Non-compliance with those principles makes the State complicit in acts of
torture or other ill-treatment and responsible for an internationally wrongful act.
78.
Therefore, torture-tainted information, even when not intended to be used in
court proceedings, must be treated in the same way that a court would treat evidence
obtained by torture or other ill-treatment. The Special Rapporteur reiterates that
every use of torture-tainted information is encouragement of torture or ill-treatment
after the fact, and therefore establishes complicity in such acts and a failure to prevent
the next round of torture or other ill-treatment.
79.
States cannot resort to diplomatic assurances as a safeguard against torture or
other ill-treatment where there is a real risk of such acts. Such assurances are
incapable of mitigating the responsibility of the State that relies on the information so
obtained.
80.
Executive agencies should be governed by detailed guidelines to avoid
complicity in such acts and reflect all international standards required by the
prohibition of torture and other ill-treatment.
81.
To ensure accountability in intelligence cooperation, truly independent
intelligence review and oversight mechanisms should be established and enhanced.
The Special Rapporteur commends the guidelines proposed by the Special
Rapporteur on human rights while encountering terrorism in his 2010 report
A/HRC/14/4659 as a starting point for further development.
B.
Recommendations
82.
Regarding the use of torture-tainted information in any proceedings, all States
shall:
(a)
Reaffirm the absolute and non-derogable nature of the exclusionary
rule;
(b)
Review criminal investigation practices to promote professional
standards and eliminate confessions as the primary or sole evidence necessary for a
prosecution;
(c)
Ensure that legislation concerning evidence presented in any proceedings
is brought into line with the exclusionary rule in order to exclude explicitly and
declare inadmissible any evidence or extrajudicial statement obtained under torture
or other ill-treatment at any state of any proceedings, irrespective of the classification
of treatment as torture or other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or
punishment;
(d)
Ensure that the exercise of discretion by national authorities in
circumstances where torture or other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or
punishment is alleged is prohibited;
(e)
Ensure that the use of real or other evidence obtained as an indirect
result of acts of torture or other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or
punishment is prohibited and excluded from any proceedings;
59
Principles 31-35
19
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents