49
42.
The proper conduct of deportation operations depends to a large extent on the
quality of the staff assigned to escort duties. Clearly, escort staff must be selected with the
utmost care and receive appropriate, specific training designed to reduce the risk of illtreatment to a minimum. This was often far from being the case in the States Parties
visited. In some countries, however, special training had been organised (methods and means
of restraint, stress and conflict management, etc.). Moreover, certain management strategies
had had a beneficial effect: the assignment of escort duties to staff who volunteered,
combined with compulsory rotation (in order to avoid professional exhaustion syndrome and
the risks related to routine, and ensure that the staff concerned maintained a certain emotional
distance from the operational activities in which they were involved) as well as provision, on
request, of specialised psychological support for staff.
43.
The importance of establishing internal and external monitoring systems in an
area as sensitive as deportation operations by air cannot be overemphasised. The CPT
observed that in many countries, specific monitoring systems had, unfortunately, been
introduced only after particularly serious incidents, such as the death of deportees.
44.
Deportation operations must be carefully documented. The establishment of a
comprehensive file and a deportation record, to be kept for all operations carried out by the
units concerned, is a basic requirement. Information on abortive deportation attempts should
receive special attention and, in particular, the reasons for abandoning a deportation operation
(a decision taken by the escort team on managerial orders, a refusal on the part of the captain
of the aircraft, violent resistance on the part of the deportee, a request for asylum, etc.) should
be systematically recorded. The information recorded should cover every incident and every
use of means of restraint (handcuffs; ankle cuffs; knee cuffs; use of self-defence techniques;
carrying the deportee on board; etc.).
Other means, for instance audiovisual, may also be envisaged, and are used in
some of the countries visited, in particular for deportations expected to be problematic.
In addition, surveillance cameras could be installed in various areas (corridors providing
access to cells, route taken by the escort and the deportee to the vehicle used for transfer to the
aircraft, etc.).
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents