3XEOLFDWLRQRI&37YLVLWUHSRUWV
3XEOLFDWLRQRI&37YLVLWUHSRUWV
,QWURGXFWLRQ
26. Fifteen CPT visit reports were published during the period covered by this
General Report, confirming once again the well-established trend of States deciding
to lift the veil of confidentiality and place the Committee’s findings in the public
domain. At the time of writing, 258 of the 301 reports so far drawn up have been
published.
A State-by-State table showing the current situation as regards publication of
CPT visit reports is set out in Appendix 6. The Russian Federation continues to
constitute a notable exception to the above-mentioned trend; however, there have
recently been indications that the Russian authorities are rethinking their position on
this matter.
The CPT regrets that authorisation has still not been given for publication of
the report transmitted to NATO more than four years ago on the Committee’s visit
in 2007 to places of deprivation of liberty in Kosovo7 under the authority of KFOR.
27. In its Recommendation 1968 (2011) on “Strengthening torture prevention
mechanisms in Europe”, the Parliamentary Assembly invites the Committee of
Ministers to set in motion the procedure of amending the Convention establishing
the CPT in order to permit the automatic publication of the Committee’s visit
reports and of the responses of the States concerned, subject to the possibility for a
State to request postponement of publication for up to six months after transmission
of the visit report.
It is self-evident that the timely publication of the CPT’s visit reports can only
increase the impact of its work. As has been repeatedly emphasised, authorising
publication of visit reports can therefore be seen as one of the most important means
of cooperating with the Committee. Nevertheless, the CPT has some misgivings as
regards the proposal to provide for the automatic publication of the Committee’s
visit reports no later than six months after their transmission. There may be
exceptional situations when the rapid publication of a visit report would do more
harm than good. More generally, the CPT is concerned that undermining the
principle of confidentiality by providing for the automatic publication of its visit
reports could upset the balance in the Convention’s provisions, to the detriment of
the Committee’s future cooperation with States.
7.
All references to Kosovo, whether to the territory, institutions or population, in this general report shall be
understood in full compliance with United Nations Security Council Resolution 1244 and without prejudice to the
status of Kosovo.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents