Date of reply
21 September 2005
State party response
Pursuant to the Committee’s request of
7 June 2005 on follow-up measures taken, the
State party informed the Committee that the
complainant will be permitted to return to French
territory if he so wishes and provided with a
special residence permit under article L.523-3 of
the Code on the entry and stay of foreigners. This
is made possible by a judgement of the Bordeaux
Court of Appeal, of 18 November 2003, which
quashed the decision of the Administrative
Tribunal of Limoges, of 8 November 2001. This
latter decision had confirmed Algeria as the
country to which the complainant should be
returned. In addition, the State party informs the
Committee that it is in the process of contacting
the Algerian authorities through diplomatic
channels to find out the whereabouts and state of
well-being of the complainant.
Complainant’s response
None
Case
Tebourski, 300/2006
Nationality and country of removal
if applicable
Tunisia
Views adopted on
1 May 2007
Issues and violations found
Removal - articles 3 and 22
Interim measures granted and State party
response
Granted but not acceded to by the State party10
10
The Committee also notes that the Convention (art. 18) vests it with competence to establish
its own rules of procedure, which become inseparable from the Convention to the extent that
they do not contradict it. In this case, rule 108 of the rules of procedure is specifically intended to
give meaning and scope to articles 3 and 22 of the Convention, which otherwise would only
offer asylum-seekers invoking a serious risk of torture a purely relative, if not theoretical, form
of protection. The Committee therefore considers that, by expelling the complainant to Tunisia
under the conditions in which that was done and for the reasons adduced, thereby presenting the
Committee with a fait accompli, the State party not only failed to demonstrate the good faith
required of any party to a treaty, but also failed to meet its obligations under articles 3 and 22 of
the Convention.
110
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents