CAT/OP/PRT/1
91.
The Subcommittee recommends that all newly arrived detainees, as soon as
possible and no later than 24 hours following their entry into a place of detention, be
given a thorough medical examination, including a full body examination, in order,
inter alia, to detect any signs of injuries sustained prior to the person’s admission. In
addition, the results of such examinations should be appropriately and
comprehensively recorded in a specifically designated and confidential register and, in
cases of suspicion of torture and ill-treatment, reported accordingly, as described in
rules 33 and 34 of the United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of
Prisoners (the Nelson Mandela Rules).
92.
Medical examinations should be carried out regularly and always in keeping
with the principle of medical confidentiality: no person other than medical personnel
should be present during the examination. Guards should remain out of hearing and
normally out of sight, except in the rare case where the medical staff may, for reasons
of safety, request otherwise. Medical records should be made available to the
detainees or their legal representatives upon the detainees’ request.
93.
Furthermore, the Subcommittee recommends that the State party improve its
training of medical personnel working in places of detention, particularly as regards
international standards, including the Istanbul Protocol, which is an indispensable
tool in detecting, documenting, reporting and, as such, deterring torture and illtreatment.
C.
Prisons
94.
The Subcommittee is concerned about the hybrid model of public-private
responsibility for medical services that remains in place in some prisons. In these prisons
staff of the Ministry of Health share work schedules with staff from private companies,
medical specialists working for private companies visit the prisons and inmates are treated
by employees of the Ministry of Health when they go to hospitals for treatment.
95.
The Subcommittee welcomes the State party’s plan to transfer the
responsibility for the health care of prisoners to the Ministry of Health as the single
service provider and recommends that the State party carry out this plan without
delay.
96.
The Subcommittee welcomes the fact that medical personnel are in general well
trained and that clinical files are generally well-kept and easily searchable. No major
concerns were identified in relation to the preparation of medicines for distribution, with
the exception of Porto Prison. At Porto Prison medications were removed from their
packaging well in advance of delivery, deposited in containers and later transferred to other
individual containers and distributed. This method left medications exposed for hours to
humidity and possible contamination and increased the risk of mistakes during their
distribution.
97.
The Subcommittee recommends that the current practice of distribution of
medications at Porto Prison be modified and that medications remain in a blister pack
until they are administered in order to retain their properties and for reasons of
hygiene.
98.
The Subcommittee notes that medical care in prisons is carried out by the polyclinics
in the prisons, and that the services provided are based on demand from the inmates. The
Subcommittee is, however, concerned that in all the prisons visited inmates reported
difficulties in obtaining access to doctors. Requests to see a doctor were usually placed
through the guard, and no registry of the requests was kept. It was therefore difficult to
evaluate the availability of medical consultation at the polyclinic. Inmates also had access
to some specialist psychiatric, psychological and dental treatment within the prisons, but
the delegation was informed that that was a very limited resource and hence of limited
availability to the inmates. Specialist treatment not available in the prison was provided in
coordination with nearby hospitals, but the waiting time was often long and the problem
was at times compounded by a lack of transport or escort. The Subcommittee considers that
16
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents