Night rounds
Daily life
Poverty in detention
Protection of
property
Administrative
detention
centre
Administrative
detention
141
Physical conditions of accommodation
Access to open air spaces
the expense of the reintegration efforts of other detainees and do not burden the
treatment of the entire prison population.
The public authorities must put more thought into the nature of the treatment of youth
returning from zones of conflict, since it has been observed that incarceration cannot
be an undifferentiated method of treating a phenomenon that affects several hundreds
of people with varying degrees of intensity.
The Contrôleur général deems that waking detainees up several times at night, for
long periods sometimes, is likely to violate their rights to physical integrity and
dignity, and to constitute inhumane and degrading treatment, all the more so as other
measures (checking of the bars, allocation of cells close to the guard posts, etc.) are
already implemented simultaneously, to ensure the security of the institution and
prevent jailbreaks.
People lacking sufficient financial resources must be able to benefit from aid, in kind,
that allows them to use a telephone for free, even if a portion of the cash aid of 20
euros can cover these costs.
The Contrôleur général stated that the aid in kind must be given unconditionally to
all people recognised by the CPU as lacking sufficient financial resources.
In certain institutions, receiving study grants makes people lacking sufficient
financial resources ineligible for the cash aid of 20 euros. The Contrôleur général
recommended that the amount of the study grants should not be taken into account
when examining their financial situation.
The Contrôleur général questions the possibility of allowing people lacking sufficient
financial resources to have a certain nest egg, through which they can accumulate
their savings, month after month, from the cash aid of 20 euros or their study grant,
in order to make atypical purchases, on the authorisation of the head of the institution.
The CGLPL renewed the recommendation formulated in its Opinion dated 10 June
2010 pertaining to the protection of the property of detainees, stating that the
compensation for lost or damaged property should be determined using the value of
the new property.
The physical conditions of accommodation of detainees are unsatisfactory in several
cases, certain rooms require a complete renovation, others in basements are cramped,
cold and noisy; in other places, the treatment is rudimentary and in one building, only
the administrative rooms are air-conditioned and the protection against mosquitoes is
not suited to the local conditions.
In a few cases, in buildings that are otherwise in a good condition, the treatment of
the detainees is close to that of imprisonment, where the detainee is only allowed
outside rarely and where the detainees leave the accommodation building only for
common meals and administrative formalities.
1
3
3
3
3
3
3
1
1
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents